A conversation with C.J. Sansom, author of Dominion, about the definition of historical fiction and his fascination with history
Could you tell us about your inspiration for writing Dominion?
Everyone who studies history seriously considers counterfactuals if a particular event, or decision, had gone differently, what would the effects on history have been? And of course one intriguing theme is what would have happened if Britain had been defeated or surrendered in 1940.
What drew you to the particular era that your book depicts? What are some of the challenges and/or delights about writing about this time?
As well as the Tudor era, I have always been very interested in European and British history before, during, and after the Second World War, and Winter in Madrid is also set within this broad period. Dominion's setting is Britain in 1952 , the year I was born. Although it is an alternate history and many things are different, I try to catch the atmosphere of 1950 s Britain in such things as the general drabness, the intense social conservatism, but also the importance of personal integrity as epitomized in characters like David and Sarah. It was very interesting to create characters rooted in a time which I can just remember, as well as little details like the fact that everybody smoked, and it was routine for dogs to do their business in the street! One of the challenges, which I would have had even writing about the real world rather than an alternate history, is that events and political figures are still, just, within range of memory, as are the political ideas. I knew I would get criticism for my portrayal of how some political figures and political parties respond to defeat, but I believe these to be plausible, or would not have proceeded as I have.
You are very well known for your Shardlake mysteries set in Tudor England, as well as Winter in Madrid. What premises did you use to transport yourself (and readers) to another time period? How do you go about research and incorporating it into fiction?
That is the $ 64,000 question for a historical novelist. I am fortunate in that I am a history nerd, and have spent much of the last forty years reading and thinking about history. I don't have the knowledge of a professional academic, but think I am fairly well rooted in the mid-sixteenth and mid-twentieth centuries.
Whenever I have chosen the exact topic I'm going to write about, I always research the particular subject as carefully as I can, including looking at original documentation from the period wherever possible. This takes two to three months and I'm sure that much of each novel is written in my subconscious during that time. Then when I write, I always try to strike that essential balance between burdening the reader with a mass of historical facts and giving the flavor of the time. That's the key thing: having the character and stories integrated with "the world of the piece."
Do you believe your historical fiction conveys a message or theme relevant to our world today? If so, what do you think it is? If not, how do you think readers can find common ground with the characters in your story?
Everyone, I think, who writes historical novels or, for that matter, factual books, does so from the perspective of their own time. I don't think there is such a thing as a general "message" or "theme" in historical fiction everyone writes from the point of view of their own ideas, conscious or unconscious. I am sure my own books reflect my own position on the democratic Left. The only book where I have deliberately conveyed a message is Dominion, where the message is how easy, and how dangerous, it is to fall into politics defined by nationalism.
As for common ground with the characters, a difficult balance has to be drawn between someone intelligible to the modern world but with the different mindset of another time. This is much easier for the 1940s than the 1540s!
Can you tell us about your next project?
I am going back to Tudor England and the Shardlake series, with a book called Lamentation, which will be set around the jockeying for power between religious and political factions at the court of the dying Henry VIII, and which will prominently feature his last wife, Catherine Parr. It will be the last in the series set during the reign of Henry VIII, but I hope to continue it under his successors.
This interview originally appeared on HistoricalBoys.Blogspot.com in March 2014 and is reprinted here with the permission of the interviewer, fellow historical novelist C. W. Gortner. He welcomes visitors at CWGortner.com.
A Conversation with C.J. Sansom, author of Winter in Madrid
What inspired you to write a book about Spain and
specifically about the period of time after the Spanish Civil War?
I first studied the Spanish Civil War as my undergraduate special subject at University, so gained a very good introduction to sources in English on the period. My course stopped in 1939 with Franco's victory but I was interested in reading on and seeing what happened to Spain during the Second World War, and decided I would like to write a spy novel set in that period. I worked as a lawyer for many years and by the time I gave that up in 2000 and had the time to write, books about the Civil War and the 1940s were starting to appear in Spain. My reading Spanish was not really good enough to use untranslated books as source material, but there were several books by English historians, and also I had managed to track down a number of books and memoirs written by journalists and British diplomats who were in Spain at the period. Meanwhile I had been visiting Spain and especially Madrid for a number of years, and managed to get items like a map of contemporary Madrid, coins and stamps -- and also a three-volume book of photographs of 20th-century Madrid. I also visited all the locations mentioned in the novel. The British Embassy is still in the same street, but the old building has gone to be replaced with a hideous modern building, so I had to imagine the old one.
Both Spain and the country's modern history fascinated me from the time I first began to learn about them in the 1970s. I felt that quite a lot had been written about the Civil War, with an emphasis on Barcelona, and I wanted to write about what life in Madrid was like after its conquest by Franco, Madrid being my favorite Spanish city. There are many British novels about the Second World War and I wanted to write about Spain as a wartime setting that no-one had really done before -- a forgotten corner of the Second World War.
Other than your studies of Spanish History, can you find any other inspiration for Winter in Madrid from your life?
Things in my personal life that helped inspire the book, perhaps that I was brought up on public-school novels [note: British public-school is similar to US private or preparatory school] and became interested in that whole into war public school ethos and the oddballs it often produced -- rebels like Sandy and Bernie and conformists like Harry who sometimes found themselves questioning things in the very different world of the war. Also, brought up in the 1960s and the early days of women's liberation, I was interested in how women can change and become more assertive. With the character of Barbara I wanted to portray a woman who in her very different time, grows from "a mouse to a lion." Barbara is actually the main character of the book -- the one who develops most and who provides the narrative glue that holds everyone else's story together.
How accurate would you say the history and politics of your novel are? Do you feel some sense of responsibility to be factually accurate when one writes historical fiction?
I think it is important for a historical novelist never to consciously mislead the audience. So everything about what was going on politically at the period is accurate, and I have made the setting as authentic as I can. On one or two occasions where I have made small alterations to historical fact, I have said so in the Historical Note. The characters, apart from brief appearances by real people as mentioned in the Historical Note, are all fictitious. Of course I have a personal slant on what is going on -- every historian does, and a historical novelist more so. It will not take the reader long to realize that I do not like Franco or his regime.
Do you think your Spanish readers will find Winter in Madrid authentic?
Whether it will be convincing to people who still remember those years I do not know -- I very much hope it feels authentic to them, and in a way the book is written for them because the terribly hard lives they led in the 1940s have in many ways been forgotten. But I must wait and see what people think. I am very much aware that pretty much every Spanish family has a parent or grandparent who suffered during the Civil War at the hands of one side or the other, and during the years of hunger that followed.
Can you expand on how the Spanish Civil War and the Franco years affected Spain versus the rest of Europe?
I think in many ways the Spanish Civil War and the Franco years had opposite effects in Spain and in the rest of Europe. In Europe the war has in many ways been viewed as the ultimate story of political struggles between fascism, democracy and communism, often perhaps idealized. In Spain nothing approaching impartial analysis could be written about the Civil War under the Franco regime, and then there were the long years of the pacto de olvido -- the pact of forgetting, when people deliberately did not mention the Civil War, perhaps because of the passion that it still evoked. That left Europeans and perhaps particularly English historians to write about this fascinating and terrible period. However in the last decade Spaniards have begun studying the Civil War and the 1940s with new interest.
Why do you think the Spanish Civil War and its aftermath havent been as freely discussed in Spain?
I'm hesitant to comment too freely on this matter, because I am not a Spaniard. But I think the sheer weight of suffering of the Civil War, together with the legacy of fear left by the Franco regime, has meant that Spaniards have understandably preferred to avoid discussing the past, until recently. But perhaps it is now time.
History is a subject where it is very easy to remember what suits us in an ignorant and distorted way; especially where conflicts between nations and ideologies are concerned. I hope reasoned study of the past can lead to a better understanding of it and, if not to impartiality, which is not necessarily a good thing, to realize that it isn't all angels on one side and devils on the other, and that a lot of innocent people get caught in the middle of historical conflicts.
Why are you drawn to write about the past?
I find myself drawn to write about the past because ever since my student days I have thought imaginatively about what it must have been like for people to live in the past, and have found myself particularly drawn to the moral dilemmas the literate classes often find themselves in at times of ideological conflict -- whether Reformation England or the Second World War. In US history I guess the time that choices were starkest was during the American Civil War. Also, knowing that I am middle-aged in some ways I find the past more accessible than our present world of computer technology, celebrity culture, casual violence and globalization. Perhaps that is why the only non-historical piece I have written is a novella set a hundred years in the future.
Unless otherwise stated, this interview was conducted at the time the book was first published, and is reproduced with permission of the publisher. This interview may not be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the copyright holder.
Members review books pre-publication. Read their opinions in First Impressions
Win 5 books, each week in July!
Solve this clue:
and be entered to win..
Visitors can view some of BookBrowse for free. Full access is for members only.
Your guide toexceptional books
BookBrowse seeks out and recommends books that we believe to be best in class. Books that will whisk you to faraway places and times, that will expand your mind and challenge you -- the kinds of books you just can't wait to tell your friends about.