BookBrowse Reviews Lavinia by Ursula K. Le Guin

BookBrowse:

A book of passion and war and the cost of war, set in ancient Italy

When thinking of the epics that tell the tales of Odysseus, Achilles and Aeneas, grand scenes come to mind. Characters are larger than life, battles are loud and bloody, and the gods are an ever-present influence over the fortunes of their heroes. If the reader approaches Lavinia with these expectations, they will be disappointed. It's not an epic; it's a quiet tale, small and contained. It tells of the things that would have concerned the women of that time – tending to the hearth and performing home rituals, caring for their children, ministering to the wounded in battle -- common, mundane matters. Battles happen in the background for the most part. There are no marble-columned palaces here; what action there is takes place in a rural community.

The reader's expectations may also be distorted by a well-publicized review by Publishers Weekly comparing Lavinia favorably to Robert Graves's I, Claudius. Any parallel that reviewer saw between the two novels is unclear, as the books aren't remotely equivalent. I, Claudius provides a sense of epic history; Lavinia reads more like a diary. Anyone selecting Lavinia based on an assumed similarity with I, Claudius will almost certainly be dissatisfied with it.

Le Guin reinvents a decidedly masculine story from the perspective of a minor female character who ultimately has great influence on history. Marion Zimmer Bradley (The Mists of Avalon) and Margaret Atwood (The Penelopiad) have both used this technique, but unlike their writings, Le Guin's novel shows no trace of feminism. It's purely feminine from start to finish.

Some interesting plot choices bring Lavinia's story to life. The gods are a huge part of the mythology behind Aeneas's tale. But, like Alessandro Baricco's An Iliad (2006), Le Guin opts to leave the gods out of her story entirely. People familiar with the epic poem may find this choice objectionable. Omitting the gods as characters in this novel, however, makes the tale more human and believable. It allows the reader to sympathize with the various characters' motivations. People in Lavinia act and react based on human emotions – jealousy, love, sorrow – instead of events taking place merely because the gods willed it. The result is a strong, realistic tale, as opposed to another retelling of a well-known myth.

One of the most interesting aspects of the novel is Le Guin's inclusion of Vergil's shade as an important character, using the relationship between it and Lavinia to explore the dynamics of creator and creation. Lavinia narrates the tale explaining that she's "contingent" on the poet's imagination. She exists only because he created her, and is immortal because her death is unrecorded. While at times a bit confusing, it adds a layer of complexity that work well within the confines of the novel.

Lavinia's strength is the depth of Le Guin's imagination. Lavinia is a fully fleshed out character. The novel is rich with detail, and Le Guin's scholarship is evident. It won't be for everyone, but readers who take pleasure in learning what day-to-day life was like in a distant era will find Lavinia worth their time.

This review was originally published in The BookBrowse Review in May 2008, and has been updated for the May 2009 edition. Click here to go to this issue.

This review is available to non-members for a limited time. For full access become a member today.