Book Club Discussion Questions
In a book club? Subscribe to our Book Club Newsletter and get our best book club books of 2025!
Please be aware that this discussion guide will contain spoilers!
- What do you think Owl represents in the book?
-
Why did Delpha reject Emilie instead of cherishing her as the only surviving child of the family?
-
What do you think about the phenomenon commonly called the Sight? Have you ever met anyone who possessed it to any degree?
-
Why didn't Emilie run for help when her mother drowned?
-
What drove Emilie to work in the stables as a child despite social disapproval and her mother's insistence that she give up horses for embroidery?
-
What social conventions did Emilie defy throughout her life?
-
What were some of the milestones in Emilie's journey to independence?
-
Compare Emilie's marriages. How much control did she have over either?
-
Given the stereotype of Arkansas being backward and redneck, were you surprised to learn that many well-educated, cultured people settled in the state?
-
How do the rising tensions about slavery impact the relationship between the McCains and Cathcarts?
-
What role did traumatic loss play in Emilie's relationships with Keller and Walker? Do you think she'd have taken up with either man without that catalyst?
-
How did Star's return help Emilie recover from the traumatic events surrounding Rose's birth?
-
Discuss Emilie's decision to exchange babies. Was it a good de¬cision? Would she have made it had she not been caught by post¬partum depression?
-
Why did Emilie choose Miranda over Walker?
-
Consider the relationship between Emilie and Caleb. Did his revelation startle you? Why or why not?
-
Will Caleb ever follow Emilie to Texas?
-
Were any of the killings in the book justified? Why or why not?
-
Have you read India Hayford's earlier novel, The Song of the Blue Bottle Tree? If so, how do the two compare?
-
To what audience would you recommend Days of Sun and Shadow? Is there another book or author you feel has a similar theme or style?
-
Overall, what did you think of Days of Sun and Shadow? (No spoilers in this topic, please.)
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of A John Scognamiglio Book. Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.