Book Club Discussion Questions
In a book club? Subscribe to our Book Club Newsletter and get our best book club books of 2025!
Please be aware that this discussion guide will contain spoilers!
-
When we first meet Hector, he feels completely out of place at the De Villiers' party,
but he is determined to see the woman who captured his heart years ago. What first impressions of Valérie did you create, as seen through Hector's eyes? How does
Valérie compare to his memories of her?
-
As she watches Hector perform in Chapter 6, how does Nina change her understanding
of her own special powers? What social distinctions become clear in Chapter 7 when
Nina is criticized for doing levitation tricks? What would you try to achieve if you had
Hector and Nina's supernatural ability?
-
In chapter 2, we learn that Nina's sister, Madelena, had married a "respectable physician" she'd known since they were children. The marriage pleases the family but
appears devoid of romance. How is Nina able to believe so strongly in romantic love,
despite society's emphasis on practical matters and status?
-
The gathering at Oldhouse includes Camille, Nina's mother, her elder sister Madelena
who is visibly pregnant, and Nina's twin great aunts: Lise and Linette. What does
Nina learn about womanhood as she grows up, and who does she learn these lessons
from?
-
Would Valérie and Hector's marriage have been a happy one? What is the root of her
cruelty: Regret? Materialism? Or is it simply part of her true temperament?
-
Discuss the customs of the novel's time period—including the clothing styles—and
the architectural features that make Loisail unique. What would you enjoy the most
about living in this time and place? Which aspects would be the most difficult for
you?
-
How is wealth gained and lost in the novel? What does it take for a woman to be deemed valuable in Loisail's social circles? Would you ever be tempted to marry for money or out of impatience?
-
Four men are particularly central to the plot: Hector, Luc, Gaetan, and Étienne. What traits do they value in women? What does it take for them to gain the admiration of their peers? How does gender affect privilege in Loisail?
-
What is meaningful about Hector's beetles? What do they say about the way he and Nina see the world?
-
How were you predicting that the duel would end?
-
Though Nina and Hector can propel inanimate objects into motion, what does it take to reverse the dynamics of unrequited love? What does the novel say about the limitations of human power when it comes to matters of the heart?
-
How does The Beautiful Ones enhance your experience of other novels by Silvia Moreno Garcia? What is unique about her approach to the magic of love?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Thomas Dunne Books. Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.