Book Club Discussion Questions
In a book club? Subscribe to our Book Club Newsletter and get our best book club books of 2025!
Please be aware that this discussion guide will contain spoilers!
-
Lena lives alternate realities with different significant others from her past. How do these
experiences challenge Lena's initial beliefs about relationships and love?
-
How does Lena's journey of self-discovery evolve over the course of the different realities she experiences? What insights does she gain about herself with each new experience?
-
Explore the impact of Lena's breakup with Kevin on her perspective towards love,
marriage, and happiness. Do you think this event initiated her journey?
-
How do Lena's experiences with the men from her past influence her views on love and
companionship? Consider her relationships with Sebastian, Nathan, Mike, Colm,
Christian, Derrick, Marcus, and Del in your discussion. What does she learn about
herself in each of these snapshots of life?
-
Discuss the roles of Lena's aunt Rosie and best friend Frankie. How do these supporting characters facilitate Lena's journey of self-discovery? What do they contribute to her attitude and approach in each new situation she's in?
-
Examine the themes of fate, missed connections, and second chances as portrayed in
the novel. Does it make you think back to any personal "what-if" moments in your own
life?
-
The novel presents Lena in various scenarios and locations: cities, farms, and the sea.
How do these environments contribute to what Lena experiences with the men she's
with?
-
Discuss how Lena's mother's romantic disappointments influenced her current feelings
about love and commitment. Discuss how familial experiences can shape our approach
towards our relationships.
-
Consider the novel's exploration of marriage and motherhood. In what ways does Lena
learn about herself through these roles, and how do they contribute to her ability to open herself up to new possibilities?
-
Society and media culture so often places emphasis on finding "the one." Do you
subscribe to the "soulmate" theory or, rather, believe that any number of people could
ultimately be your forever love?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of William Morrow. Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.