Book Club Discussion Questions
In a book club? Subscribe to our Book Club Newsletter and get our best book club books of 2025!
Please be aware that this discussion guide will contain spoilers!
-
What do you think of the way Sam broke off with Andrew? Can you defend him?
-
Why do you think Susanna decide to have a baby with Sam? Would it have been better if she'd gone with another friend as the donor? Or with an anonymous donor?
-
Do you think that Rupert is the father of Vera's sons? Do you think that Eleanor believes that they are?
-
Why did Rupert resume the relationship with Vera? Why did Vera resume the relationship after Rupert had left her so abruptly?
-
Why did the Reverend Falkes give Rupert his last name? Why did he prefer him above the other orphans?
-
Jim and Eleanor moved on from their relationship very differently. Why did Eleanor move on more easily than Jim? Why do you think Jim invited Eleanor to his wedding?
-
Was Jim's a failed life? Would he have been more successful if he had not been in love Eleanor? Why was he stuck on his past? Was Rupert also stuck? Was Anne?
-
Why did Anne marry Jim? What was it about him that make her want him?
-
Do you have a favorite among the 5 Falkes boys? Which one? Why?
What are the virtues of each? Harry? Will? Sam? Jack? Tom?
What are the deficits of each?
Does Eleanor have a favorite? Did Rupert?
-
Did Eleanor and Rupert love each other? Would you say that they had a good marriage? What makes a good marriage?
-
How do the couples deal with infidelity? Why do some marriages survive infidelity and others don't? How important is fidelity to a marriage?
-
Do you think that a wife or husband usually "knows" when the other spouse is having an affair even if he or she doesn't acknowledge it?
-
How did Rupert's childhood make him the man he grew up to be? Do you see a connection between his childhood and his relationships with Eleanor, his father-in-law, his sons, Vera?
-
Both Rupert and Harry have affairs at 40. Do you think their behavior is a typical midlife crisis, or is there something more going on?
-
Do all marriages involve secrets? Do all relationships? If you found out that someone close to you had been keeping a big secret, how would that change your relationship?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Crown. Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.