Reading Guide Questions
Please be aware that this discussion guide may contain spoilers!
- Much like the author, Slava Gelman has to figure out how to write stories that will seem credible, in
his case to the officials who assess restitution claims. How does he meet the challenge? What does he
determine helps make a story believable? Which of the three "false narratives" included in the book was
most engaging, and why?
- Did you sympathize with Slava's desire to escape South Brooklyn? Does it seem like a vibrant
community? Is it a good example of what refugees from a less fortunate place can become in America?
Or is the community missing something that Slava considers vital to good citizenship in his adopted
- A Replacement Life has both melancholy and tragic elements. For instance, Slava feels great regret over having abandoned his
grandmother, and he and his family pay dearly for his and Grandfather's scheme. But A Replacement Life contains much humor as well.
What examples of comedy can you recall? How well do they co-exist with the more somber notes of the book? Why do you think Fishman
wrote a book that works in these various tones? How does the novel fit in the tradition of Jewish humor?
- What lessons do you think Slava has taken away at novel's end? How do you think he will live his life now? What do you think he will
do professionally, and what do you think he has understood about what's important in a life partner?
- Why do you think the middle generationthat is, Slava's parentsplays such a relatively minor role in the book? Why does Fishman
place such emphasis on the relationship of the grandchildren and grandparents?
- Which of Slava's love interests was more sympathetic or compelling, and why? How do Slava's perceptions of Vera and Arianna shift
over the course of the novel? What does Slava learn from these women? With whom do you think he would be happier?
- Grandfather defends his scheme to Slava by saying: "'Maybe I didn't suffer in the exact way I need to have suffered'[Grandfather]
flicked a finger at the envelope'but they made sure to kill all the people who did. We had our whole world taken out from under us. No
more dances, no holidays, no meals with your mother at the stove . . . Do you know what we came back to after the war? Tomatoes the
size of your head. They'd fertilized them with human ash. You follow?'" To what extent do you empathize with Grandfather's logic? Do you
think he and his confederates in South Brooklyn are criminals? Do you think there's any justification for what they are doing?
- In what way does the novel affirm the American Dream, that is, the idea that great rewardsmaterial comfort, professional
advancement, a sense of belongingawait those immigrants to America who work hard? In what ways does the novel challenge that
- In what ways is Slava an appealing character? In what ways is he frustrating, small-minded, or disappointing? Did you root for him?
What is Slava trying to figure out for himself in the course of the novel?
- Who was your favorite character, and why?
- Compare Grandfather and Israel. In what ways are the two men alike, and in what ways dissimilar? Whom did you like more, and why?
- Apart from the general fact that many first novels draw on autobiographical elements, Fishman's specific backgroundhe immigrated
from the former Soviet Union at only a slightly older age than Slava, and spent his first years in America in roughly the same area as
Slavamakes a strong case that some of the material in A Replacement Life comes from real life. However, just as many detailsthe
narrator's crime, for oneseem invented. In what ways did your awareness of the author's personal history inform or inhibit your
appreciation of the novel? Do you think that history makes the writing of such a novel easier or more difficult?
- In the novel-long tug-of-war between Slava and Grandfather, whom did you root for, and why? Do you think Slava learns anything
from Grandfather by the end of A Replacement Life? Does Grandfather learn anything from Slava? How has their relationship changed in
the course of the novel?
- "You must know these things," Slava thinks as he imagines his descendants at Grandmother's grave at novel's end, "for you will
replace me as I am replacing them." What is the title of the novel referring to? How many types of "life replacement" can you count in
- What makes someone American, or Russian? If one continues to live in the country one was born, the answer is easy, but for those
who had to give up one homeland for another, what determines where on the spectrum one falls? Where on the spectrum does Slava
begin the novel, and where does he end it? In what ways does he realize he was wrong about what it means to "be Russian" and what it
means to "be American"? Is it possible for an immigrant to be fully one or the other?
- "It's family, Slavik," Grandfather says in persuading Slava to agree to forge the older man's claim. "I would give my right arm for you if
that's what it took. That's family." What does A Replacement Life say about our obligations to family? Would you ever commit a crime for
a loved one?
- How much distance does A Replacement Life find between what's lawful and moral? What is an individual's obligation in circumstances
where he or she finds the law unjust?
- How do Slava's aspirations for himselfprofessionally, romantically, creativelydiffer from what he comes to discover would make him
- What does A Replacement Life say about the traditional aspirations of Jewish parents for their children? Could the Gelmans have
avoided their heartache if Slava's parents and grandparents had found a way to support his dreams of becoming a writer? Could that
have been achieved if Slava had elected a different course?
- What meaning does the Gelmans' former homelandthe Soviet Union when they left, now Belarushave for them? How do you
explain their simultaneous disdain of the place they left behindcertainly of the way it treated its Jewsand their clinging to its ways of
life, culturally and emotionally?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Harper Perennial.
Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.