Reading Guide Questions
Please be aware that this discussion guide may contain spoilers!
- How do the Dickinson and Wharton epigraphs at the beginning of the book relate to and set the stage for the novel? In what way do they put the book in the context of a larger literary tradition? Are there other books or authors who seem appropriate for epigraphs for this book? Why?
- Some of the earliest scenes Esme shares with the reader are those from her childhood in India. What do these scenes, particularly the ones on pages 48, reveal about Esme and her family? What do they reveal about their place in time and society?
- Iris notes on page 10 that sometimes she feels as though she is leading a subterranean existence. What does she mean? In what ways is this type of existence similar to or different from those of the other female characters?
- Iris and Alex seem to live in their own world, keeping otherseven Alexs wife and Iriss loverson the outside. How does the author let you know that Iris doesnt like Fran without coming out and saying so? How does she reveal that Alex and Luke dont like each other? How do these revelations serve a function in the progress of the novel?
- OFarrells novel is steeped in secrets. As the story of Esme and Kitty unfolds simultaneously with the story of Iris and Alex, OFarrell offers clues about the true nature of the relationships between these characters. What effect does this have on your compassion for them? How do these two stories relate to each other?
- Why is Esme purportedly admitted to Cauldstone? Why do you think she was sent there, and never sent home? Is she really mad? Give examples from the book to support your opinion.
- Esme is both taken aback and fascinated by many things that Iris shows and tells her. What does Esme think is so remarkable about Iris? How are Iris and Esme similar? How are they different?
- On page 57, Iris discovers some of the more outrageous reasons that women in the mid-nineteenth and early twentieth centuries were sent to mad houses like Cauldstone. Given how life was during that period, according to the novels descriptions, what do you think drove this trend? Do you think changes have occurred in our view and treatment of women who dont behave? Why or why not?
- OFarrell creates distinct voices for the three main characters in her novel and shifts between these points of view to tell her story. Why do you think the author made this choice? What do these different voices reveal about Iris, Esme, and Kitty? How does this technique affect your reading experience?
- Identify some of the various ways in which the title, The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox, relates to the story. What does Esmes description of her vanishing act on page 91 symbolize?
- The references to Kitty stealing Esmes jacket and the image of Esme holding on to baby Hugo are introduced early to distract the reader from the true secret of this story. When did you figure out what it was that Kitty really took from Esme? How did it affect your opinion of Kitty? Do you feel sympathy for her? Why or why not?
- How does Esme and Kittys secret change things for Iris? Is Alex right when he tells Iris, Its only ever been you and you know its only ever been me? Now that the full weight of Esmes tragedy has unfolded, do you think Iris will choose to be with him or with Luke?
- Alex and Luke are both married men in love with Iris. Do you think this is why they so dislike each other? Is there a difference between their situations? Do you think Iris really loves either one of them? Why or why not?
- What do you make of the ending? What do you imagine will happen to these characters after the last page is turned? Has the author satisfied your interest in these characters? Does there seem to be an overarching message?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Harvest Books.
Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.