Andrew P

So much to love about this book. The unconventional story structure and 'roving' POV not only keeps the story fresh and active it's a great way to introduce a multi-generational perspective on an age old topic. The characters read incredibly real and accessible (wanted to hang out with them longer!) and manage to get their not insignificant points across in a manner that's fun, meaningful and not over-wrought. Zevin's take on the 'Scarlet Letter' is original, emotionally satisfying and worthily constructed for today's audience.

Though the quality of the writing is high it wasn't enough to overcome my ultimate lack of emotional connection with the people/story. Not identifying with the character's life experiences/situations probably played a part in my reading experience --though that's not always a prerequisite for relating to a book—though I also found the lack of story drive weighing down the read. Ultimately, --and this may be more of a commentary on my current state of mind-- I found myself not wanting to spend time with these characters in this depressing world.