BookBrowse Reviews Edgar and Lucy by Victor Lodato

Summary |  Excerpt |  Reading Guide |  Reviews |  Beyond the book |  Read-Alikes |  Genres & Themes |  Author Bio

Edgar and Lucy

by Victor Lodato

Edgar and Lucy by Victor Lodato X
Edgar and Lucy by Victor Lodato
  • Critics' Opinion:

    Readers' Opinion:

  • First Published:
    Mar 2017, 544 pages

    Feb 2018, 544 pages


  • Rate this book

Book Reviewed by:
BookBrowse First Impression Reviewers
Buy This Book

About this Book



A story of disappointment and grief, courage and loss, and of the resilience of humans to overcome and triumph.

28 of our 33 Bookbrowse First Impression reviewers rated Edgar and Lucy four or five stars, giving the book an overall rating of 4.4.

What it's about:

Edgar and Lucy by Victor Lodato is a wonderful book about love, loss, and reconciliation. Edgar is an eight-year-old boy who lives with his grandmother Florence and his mother Lucy. Florence, who was the nurturing woman in Edgar's life, dies unexpectedly and Edgar and Lucy must learn to love and care for each other in a whole new way. This is a book about growing up and the many ways people change through the hardships and challenges of life (Vicki R). This tale of a little boy navigating life in the face of profound sorrow and dangerous choices is engaging and gripping. Told from the perspectives of several different characters readers are able to see all sides of Edgar and Lucy's story and root for them to find themselves and each other (Kenan R). This is a story of disappointment and grief, courage and loss, and of the resilience of humans and the ability to overcome and triumph. It illustrates just how strong and irrepressible children are and how they survive to become adults despite the misguided people around them (Marilyn J).

The book was acclaimed by many of our readers:

I would shout from the rooftops exclaiming my adoration for this novel. I could tell from the very first page that this was one that I was going to savor and enjoy (Lani S). This coming-of-age novel (and not just Edgar's coming-of-age) is one of the best I've read recently and at the last word, I sighed, wishing it would go on (Marilyn J). This book is a puzzle for me in that it is not the type of book I usually enjoy. It is a dark story, full of unhappy people, but the more I read, the more I wanted to read it. (Dorinne D). Edgar and Lucy will be in my mind and heart for a very long time, and on my bookshelf to revisit and read again (Jan B).

Reviewers who enjoyed the book commented on the well-developed characters:

The novel is filled with a cast of characters that we come to know and hold in our hearts (Beth B). They were intricate and well-rounded, intriguing and gripping, and they were why I didn't put it down until I was finished. The relationships between them were fascinating and complex (Marilyn J). Though they are all flawed we are shown that for the most part they have good hearts and good intentions (Barbara G). The author does a great job of dealing with how all people deal with sadness, grief and love in different ways. You are actually in the minds of the different main characters which makes the book especially clear on their feelings and thoughts (Donna N). This is a long epic, but it engaged me, probably because each of the characters was treated with gentleness and kindness by the author. I thought I had a bird's eye view of everyone's inner life. (Rosemary C).

Several mentioned Edgar in particular:

Lodato has created a child with such wonder, imagination, humor and pathos that I wanted to grab him and hold him tightly to my chest (Lani S). Edgar is both innocent and wise yet angry and curious (Patricia L). His feelings and thoughts were so intriguing I started making notes and highlighting different passages to go back to and think about again (Jan B). Edgar's interior dialogue added depth to the story. I'm impressed with the way the author gets into Edgar's head and shows us his point of view (Elizabeth K).

Many reviewers were also impressed with the author's writing style:

The best part about the book was the writing! It is ethereal; here and there imagining and describing feelings and viewpoints with phrases that are almost magical - you get wisps of the ideas from the words. Beautiful. (Molly B). This is not just a great American novel, it is a great human novel. This is the finest writing I've read in a very long time. Victor Lodato deserves every literary accolade available for this one (Janet W). The language is so gorgeous that I found myself re-reading whole paragraphs just to enjoy it again (Carol F).

However, the novel's pacing in particular seemed to be an issue for several readers, although opinions differed:

Please don't follow the 50 page rule on this book. It is slow to start but I found it very interesting after about page 40. There were many things around the corner that I didn't expect (Carolyn V). By the end I loved this book, but the first third was pretty tough to slog through. If you're having trouble, keep with it -- it's worth the wait! (Jane H). The only weakness I found was the last sections dragged on too long (Doris K). My one slight disappointment was in the last few chapters which I thought were rushed and made me feel bereft of the fullness of the novel (Lani S).

Those who disliked it completely seemed unable to categorize the work:

I just could not connect to the story or the characters. It's not a coming of age book, it's not a fantasy book, not a science fiction book: I think the author does not even know what kind of book he wanted to write (Catherine H).  Fantasy? Sci-fi? What is it? At 250 pages I gave up trying to connect and/or care about any of the characters. I skipped to about page 400 to see if the book made any more sense. Not to me. Dark and strange. (Judith G).

But for the most part, Edgar and Lucy left reviewers eager for more:

It is a lengthy story but I found myself not wanting it to end and as the end drew near, I started rationing out the pages. Even knowing I had a review to post I stretched it out (Jan B). I would actually reread this book and that is something I have only done perhaps 2-3 times in 60 years of reading avidly (Vicki C). I will definitely look for Lodato's other works. (Molly B). I plan to read anything else this author writes -- his work is definitely worth reading if you like literary fiction. (Elizabeth K).

Our reviewers recommend Edgar and Lucy for book group discussion and to those who enjoy literary fiction:

Edgar and Lucy is a deeply moving book and one that I highly recommend for anyone. It would be an especially good book for book clubs as there are so many potential areas of discussion. (Vicki C). The book presents multiple views of deep topics such as death, grief, depression, love, loss, family and abduction. (Kay D). I was fascinated by this book and can visualize an in-depth discussion by book club members (Doris K). This book has everything for the reader of tales: Off kilter characters; family drama; multiple viewpoints; and beautiful readable language. Highly recommended (Maggie R). If you enjoy character-driven stories illustrated with luminous prose, you will enjoy Edgar and Lucy. (Elizabeth K).

This review was originally published in The BookBrowse Review in April 2017, and has been updated for the February 2018 edition. Click here to go to this issue.

This review is available to non-members for a limited time. For full access become a member today.
Membership Advantages
  • Reviews
  • "Beyond the Book" articles
  • Free books to read and review (US only)
  • Find books by time period, setting & theme
  • Read-alike suggestions by book and author
  • Book club discussions
  • and much more!
  • Just $45 for 12 months or $15 for 3 months.
  • More about membership!

Beyond the Book:


Read-Alikes Full readalike results are for members only

If you liked Edgar and Lucy, try these:

  • The True Tale of the Monster Billy Dean jacket

    The True Tale of the Monster Billy Dean

    by David Almond

    Published 2015

    About this book

    More by this author

    From master storyteller David Almond comes a gripping, exquisitely written novel about a hidden-away child who emerges into a broken world.

  • The Story of Edgar Sawtelle jacket

    The Story of Edgar Sawtelle

    by David Wroblewski

    Published 2009

    About this book

    Born mute, speaking only in sign, Edgar Sawtelle leads an idyllic life with his parents on their farm in remote northern Wisconsin. But his life is plunged into chaos as his uncle returns, his father suddenly dies, and he is forced to flee into the wilderness with only three yearling dogs for company.

We have 4 read-alikes for Edgar and Lucy, but non-members are limited to two results. To see the complete list of this book's read-alikes, you need to be a member.
More books by Victor Lodato
Search read-alikes
How we choose read-alikes

Become a Member

Join BookBrowse today to start discovering exceptional books!

Find out more

Top Picks

  • Book Jacket: Where Coyotes Howl
    Where Coyotes Howl
    by Sandra Dallas
    Where Coyotes Howl may appear to be a classically conventional historical novel — a wide-eyed ...
  • Book Jacket: After the Miracle
    After the Miracle
    by Max Wallace
    Many people have heard one particular story about Helen Keller—how the saintly teacher, Annie ...
  • Book Jacket: The Lost Wife
    The Lost Wife
    by Susanna Moore
    The Lost Wife is a hard-hitting novella based in part on a white settler named Sarah Wakefield's ...
  • Book Jacket
    Firekeeper's Daughter
    by Angeline Boulley
    Voted 2021 Best Young Adult Award Winner by BookBrowse Subscribers

    Angeline Boulley's young adult ...

Book Club Discussion

Book Jacket
The First Conspiracy
by Brad Meltzer & Josh Mensch
A remarkable and previously untold piece of American history—the secret plot to kill George Washington

Members Recommend

  • Book Jacket

    Pieces of Blue
    by Holly Goldberg Sloan

    A hilarious and heartfelt novel for fans of Maria Semple and Emma Straub.

Win This Book
Win Girlfriend on Mars

30 Copies to Give Away!

A funny and poignant debut novel that skewers billionaire-funded space travel in a love story of interplanetary proportions.



Solve this clue:

S I F A R Day

and be entered to win..

Your guide toexceptional          books

BookBrowse seeks out and recommends the best in contemporary fiction and nonfiction—books that not only engage and entertain but also deepen our understanding of ourselves and the world around us.