BookBrowse Reviews Peony in Love by Lisa See

Summary |  Excerpt |  Reading Guide |  Reviews |  Beyond the book |  Readalikes |  Genres & Themes |  Author Bio

Peony in Love

A Novel

by Lisa See

Peony in Love by Lisa See X
Peony in Love by Lisa See
  • Critics' Opinion:

    Readers' Opinion:

  • First Published:
    Jun 2007, 272 pages
    Feb 2008, 320 pages

  • Rate this book

Book Reviewed by:
BookBrowse Review Team

Buy This Book

About this Book



A story steeped in the traditions and rituals of 17th century China that addresses the universal themes of friendship, the power of words, and the age-old desire of women to be heard

Following the runaway success of Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, which was set in a remote corner of nineteenth-century China where tradition and foot-bound women developed their own secret code for communication known as nu shu (woman's writing), Lisa See returns to tell a story set two centuries earlier in which, for a short period, wealthy women in the Yangtze delta area, often living in seclusion, published their writings.

The mid-17th century was a turbulent time for China; the Ming dynasty that had controlled China for almost 300 years (not the China we know today but the South-East corner of the continent) collapsed as the Manchus (from the North-East) invaded, raping and pillaging as they went (eventually establishing the Qing Dynasty which ruled until its collapse in 1912). During the brief period between the collapse of one dynasty and the consolidation of the next, a few brave female voices rebelled in a literary way, not only writing but publishing their poetry.

Peony In Love brings to life two 17th century writings - the opera "The Peony Pavilion which celebrates the supremacy of love over mortality, and "The Three Wives' Commentary" - musings on love inspired by "The Peony Pavilion". "The Peony Pavilion", a fifty-five scene play, which would have been performed over several days, tells the love story of a young male student and the daughter of a high official who, inconsolable in her grief at not being able to be with her beloved, starves herself to death early on in the opera rather than be married to another man (an apparently not-uncommon response by young girls of the time who had control over nothing in their lives except their own bodies).

Like other young girls of her era, Lisa See's heroine, Peony, is obsessed by "The Peony Pavilion" even before she sees it performed at her family's house, during which she spies a beautiful young man with whom she becomes besotted. Believing herself betrothed to another and in thrall to the opera, she starves herself to death - not realizing that the man she loves, Wu Ren, is the same one that her family have promised her to. After death, Peony promptly returns to earth as a "hungry ghost" wishing to be reunited with her beloved.

Which leads on to the main flow of the story in which See gives fictional heft to the lives of three historically-based women - Chen Tong, Tan Ze and Qian Yi, who collaborated to write a collection of insights about love inspired by "The Peony Pavilion", known as "The Three Wives' Commentary". Whereas, in real life the three women were all wives of Wu Ren, in See's version, the dead Chen Tong (Peony) returns from the afterlife to inhabit the souls of Wu Ren's two wives and guide their hands to write "The Three Wives' Commentary".

Peony In Love hits all the right notes to be a popular book for 21st century female readers, especially book club members. In fact, it's an absolute shoo-in for book clubs, replete as it is with talking points that explore love, loss and redemption, and plentiful details about ancient Chinese rituals and beliefs, many of which live on into modern times (such as the believe that ghosts cannot turn corners). Added to which, See's heroines, in their downtrodden determination to follow the path of intellectual freedom, are very sympathetic to a modern reader. Some readers may find the level of detail a little too much - no opportunity to extrapolate on a cultural more is left untapped, no chance to expand on a ritual or piece of writing is left unexplored. But for those many readers who read to learn as much as to be entertained, this powerful, graceful and revealing book has a great deal to offer.

The Story of Peony In Love: Tang Xianzu's "The Peony Pavilion" has caused controversy from when it was first performed in 1598 up until the current day. Almost immediately, different groups advocated that it be censored, and many scenes were cut. In 1780, the opera was blacklisted as profane, and in 1868 it was officially banned and all copies were ordered to be burned. In 2000, the Lincoln Center put on a full-length production that was temporarily delayed when the Chinese government discovered the content of the restored scenes and barred the actors, costumes and sets from leaving the country. The reason for the controversy? "The Peony Pavilion" was the first piece of fiction in the history of China in which the heroine chose her own destiny. Women of the time became entranced with the concept, and many young girls destined for arranged marriages chose to starve themselves to death so, like the heroine of the opera, they too might choose their own destinies in their next life.

In 2000, Lisa See wrote a short piece for Vogue about the Lincoln Center's production of "The Peony Pavilion", and became intrigued by the "lovesick maidens" who, on researching the era, she found were part of a much larger phenomenon. Apparently, in the mid-17th century, more women writers were being published in China's Yangzi delta than in all the rest of the world at that time - literally thousands of women. Some women published just a poem or two, but others became professionals, supporting their families with their writing. When See came across the "The Three Wives' Commentary" - the first book of its kind written by women to have been published anywhere in the world, which on publication apparently caused such a furor that the Emperor clamped down even harder on the freedoms of women, See's interest turned into an obsession - and the result is Peony in Love.

Keep reading at Lisa See's website

This review is from the February 21, 2008 issue of BookBrowse Recommends. Click here to go to this issue.

This review is available to non-members for a limited time. For full access become a member today.
Membership Advantages
  • Reviews
  • "Beyond the Book" backstories
  • Free books to read and review (US only)
  • Find books by time period, setting & theme
  • Read-alike suggestions by book and author
  • Book club discussions
  • and much more!
  • Just $10 for 3 months or $35 for a year
  • More about membership!

Support BookBrowse

Become a Member and discover books that entertain, engage & enlighten!

Join Today!

Editor's Choice

  • Book Jacket: The Last Ballad
    The Last Ballad
    by Wiley Cash
    Ella May WigginsA hundred years ago or so, farming land west of Charlotte, North Carolina was given over to giant ...
  • Book Jacket: Future Home of the Living God
    Future Home of the Living God
    by Louise Erdrich
    Louise Erdrich began Future Home of the Living God in 2002, set it aside, and picked it up again in ...
  • Book Jacket: The Last Mrs. Parrish
    The Last Mrs. Parrish
    by Liv Constantine
    Amber has lived in poverty all her life, and she has had enough. Of course, wishing to have money ...

Book Discussion
Book Jacket
The Second Mrs. Hockaday by Susan Rivers

At once a love story, a history lesson and a beautifully written tale of forgiveness.

About the book
Join the discussion!

First Impressions

  • Book Jacket

    Wonder Valley
    by Ivy Pochoda

    A visionary and masterful portrait of contemporary L.A. from the author of Visitation Street.
    Reader Reviews

Who Said...

Sometimes I think we're alone. Sometimes I think we're not. In either case, the thought is staggering.

Click Here to find out who said this, as well as discovering other famous literary quotes!

Word Play

Solve this clue:

E Dog H I D

and be entered to win..

Books that     

 & enlighten

Visitors can view some of BookBrowse for free. Full access is for members only.

Join Today!

Your guide toexceptional          books

BookBrowse seeks out and recommends books that we believe to be best in class. Books that will whisk you to faraway places and times, that will expand your mind and challenge you -- the kinds of books you just can't wait to tell your friends about.