BookBrowse Reviews Charity Girl by Michael Lowenthal

Summary |  Excerpt |  Reading Guide |  Reviews |  Beyond the book |  Readalikes |  Genres & Themes |  Author Bio

Charity Girl

by Michael Lowenthal

Charity Girl by Michael Lowenthal X
Charity Girl by Michael Lowenthal
  • Critics' Opinion:

    Readers' Opinion:

  • First Published:
    Jan 2007, 336 pages

    Jan 2008, 336 pages


  • Rate this book

Book Reviewed by:
BookBrowse Review Team
Buy This Book

About this Book



Charity Girl lays bare an ugly part of our past, when the government exercised a questionable level of authority at the expense of its citizens’ rights.

The year is 1917, America has recently joined the War in Europe. Fun-loving Frieda is out on the town catching a few minutes downtime from her tedious job as a "bundle wrapper" in a department store, a job she has taken relatively recently after fleeing her mother's house to escape marriage to the deeply unattractive and hairy-eared widower Pinchas Hersch, who is twice her age and sees marriage to her as a cheap form of childcare for his odious children.

Young and fun-loving she might be, but she's not reckless. She knows just how far she's prepared to go for a few drinks and the occasional gift, but the balance changes when she catches sight of Private Felix Morse. A romance ensues and Frieda, believing this to be the "real thing", allows Felix to go further than she has been with any other man. As it happens her beau is not only handsome and apparently decent, but also heir to a substantial fortune (a story that would seem a little too neat if it wasn't for the fact that the romance is actually based on the author's grandparents - see the backstory below).

Not long after she gets a visit at work from the formidable and humorless Mrs Sprague who informs her that Felix has tested positive for syphilis and has given her name as his last contact. A few chapters later, having lost her job following Mrs Sprague's visit, and got herself into deeper trouble by going to the camp in an attempt to find Felix, Frieda finds herself charged with prostitution and locked up with a group of women who are all undergoing a humiliating and dehumanizing course of treatment for their "social diseases". The wide range of women we meet in the detention center enables Lowenthal to explore the moral morass from multiple angles; there's the worldly prostitute, the teen runaway who is running from something far worse than the detention center; and even a trade-unionist who knows her rights - but who is there to listen to them? Cut off from the outside world, forbidden to write or receive letters, the girls are in the hands of the system and the people who administer it, who often have little more power over their destinies than the girls themselves.

The particular moment in history that Lowenthal explores will be news to most, but the tale of governments overruling the rights of those without the influence to defend themselves is familiar. Of course, this is all in the past, something like this couldn't happen in America today, could it?

The Story Behind The Book: Charity Girl was inspired by a line in Susan Sontag’s AIDS and Its Metaphors, in which she likens the incarceration of American women during World War I to the internment of Americans of Japanese ancestry during World War II. Lowenthal says, "The latter historical episode I had, of course, heard about, but not the first . . . I immediately had two thoughts: (1) how awful, and (2) what a great basis for a novel."

During World War I about 30,000 American women were rounded up on suspicion of carrying a venereal disease, of which about 15,000 were incarcerated in reformatories and detention homes—often for months at a time, with no charge of a crime, no trial, no legal recourse—while they received forcible medical treatment for venereal disease (keep in mind that the rights of women have changed dramatically in the past 100 years, for example it was not until the 19th Amendment in 1920 that USA women won the right to vote). Many of the detained women were prostitutes, but a great number, such as the protagonist of Charity Girl, were simply "charity girls" out for a bit of fun. As Lowenthal says, they "were doing nothing illicit or even unusual. Social standards change, but I don't believe the human heart does. I couldn't stop imagining what these charity girls had felt: girls who had the very same hopes and sexual urges as we do now, but who were made, for having those urges, to feel wicked. I learned that some of the detention homes had been remodeled from brothels that the Feds shut down in their anti-vice crusade. To a novelist, this fact came as a gift: a perfect setting. But could I, a man in the twenty-first century, write a novel about girls in 1918?"

While he was deciding whether to develop his new found knowledge into a novel, Michael happened to be browsing a used bookstore where he found The Story of the Massachusetts Committee on Public Safety, published at the end of World War I. He not only discovered a chapter about the "Massachusetts Committee on Prevention of Social Evils Surrounding Military Camps", but found that his great-grandfather's cousin had been on the committee - which he took as a sign that he was meant to write the book!

This family connection enabled him to start seeing the story from a personal viewpoint and he decided that one of the characters would be a wealthy Jewish businessman like his great-grandfather and that he would live in a grand house similar to that which his grandfather built in 1917. He imagined what it would be like to live in such opulence at such a time and what it would be like for a girl of lower social class such as his grandmother to fall in love with a well-to-do Bostonian (his grandfather) and be brought to live in such a lavish house. He named his main character Frieda, after his grandmother, but, instead of recreating her life, imagined what life would have been like for her if things had not worked out so well with his grandfather!

This review was originally published in The BookBrowse Review in January 2007, and has been updated for the January 2008 edition. Click here to go to this issue.

This review is available to non-members for a limited time. For full access become a member today.
Membership Advantages
  • Reviews
  • "Beyond the Book" articles
  • Free books to read and review (US only)
  • Find books by time period, setting & theme
  • Read-alike suggestions by book and author
  • Book club discussions
  • and much more!
  • Just $45 for 12 months or $15 for 3 months.
  • More about membership!


Read-alikes Full readalike results are for members only

If you liked Charity Girl, try these:

  • Ginny Gall jacket

    Ginny Gall

    by Charlie Smith

    Published 2017

    About this book

    A sweeping, eerily resonant epic of race and violence in the Jim Crow South: a lyrical and emotionally devastating masterpiece from Charlie Smith, whom the New York Public Library has said "may be America's most bewitching stylist alive."

  • Live by Night jacket

    Live by Night

    by Dennis Lehane

    Published 2013

    About this book

    More by this author

    Live by Night is a riveting epic layered with a diverse cast of loyal friends and callous enemies, tough rumrunners and sultry femmes fatales, Bible-quoting evangelists and cruel Klansmen, all battling for survival and their piece of the American dream.

Non-members are limited to two results. Become a member
Search read-alikes again
How we choose readalikes

Become a Member

Join BookBrowse today to start discovering exceptional books!

Find out more

Top Picks

  • Book Jacket: A Mystery of Mysteries
    A Mystery of Mysteries
    by Mark Dawidziak
    Edgar Allan Poe biographers have an advantage over other writers because they don't have to come up ...
  • Book Jacket: Moonrise Over New Jessup
    Moonrise Over New Jessup
    by Jamila Minnicks
    Jamila Minnicks' debut novel Moonrise Over New Jessup received the PEN/Bellwether Prize for Socially...
  • Book Jacket
    The Magician's Daughter
    by H.G. Parry
    "Magic isn't there to be hoarded like dragon's treasure. Magic is kind. It comes into ...
  • Book Jacket: The Great Displacement
    The Great Displacement
    by Jake Bittle
    On August 4, 2021, California's largest single wildfire to date torched through the small mountain ...

Book Club Discussion

Book Jacket
The Nurse's Secret
by Amanda Skenandore
A fascinating historical novel based on the little-known story of America's first nursing school.

Members Recommend

  • Book Jacket

    The Last Russian Doll
    by Kristen Loesch

    A haunting epic of betrayal, revenge, and redemption following three generations of Russian women.

  • Book Jacket

    The Lost English Girl
    by Julia Kelly

    A story of love, betrayal, and motherhood set against the backdrop of World War II and the early 1960s.

Who Said...

A library, to modify the famous metaphor of Socrates, should be the delivery room for the birth of ideas--a place ...

Click Here to find out who said this, as well as discovering other famous literary quotes!


Solve this clue:

R Peter T P P

and be entered to win..

Your guide toexceptional          books

BookBrowse seeks out and recommends the best in contemporary fiction and nonfiction—books that not only engage and entertain but also deepen our understanding of ourselves and the world around us.