BookBrowse Reviews The Last Witchfinder by James Morrow

BookBrowse:

A novel of history, adventure, science, sex, satire, absurdity, and philosophy. Historical Fiction

This review is available to non-members for a limited time. For access to our digital magazine, free books,and other benefits, become a member today.

From the book jacket: Jennet Stearne's father hangs witches for a living in Restoration England. But when this precocious child witnesses the horrifying death of her beloved Aunt Isobel, unjustly executed as a sorceress, she makes it her life's mission to bring down the Parliamentary Witchcraft Act. A self-educated "natural philosopher," Jennet is inspired in her quest by a single sentence in a cryptic letter from Isaac Newton: It so happens that in the Investigations leading first to my Conjectures concerning Light and later to my System of the World, I fell upon a pretty Proof that Wicked Spirits enjoy no essential Existence. Armed with nothing but the power of reason and her memory of Isobel's love, Jennet cannot rest until she has put the last witchfinder out of business.

Chock-full with picaresque adventures -- escapades that carry Jennet from King William's Britain to the fledgling American Colonies to an uncharted Caribbean island -- our heroine's search for justice entangles her variously in the machinations of the Salem Witch Court, the customs of her Algonquin Indian captors, the designs of a West Indies pirate band, and the bedsheets of her brilliant lover, the young Ben Franklin. Finally, in a reckless and courageous ploy, Jennet arranges to go on trial herself for sorcery, the only way she can defeat the witchfinders now and forever.

Comment: Set in the 17th-century, The Last Witchfinder is a richly detailed, cerebral tale narrated by Isaac Newton's Principia Mathematica (more about this in the sidebar) that, according to his publisher, took Morrow nine years to write. It's a book that you're likely to either love or hate. According to one of the book blurbs, written by Peter Straub (author of Ghost Story and Shadowland) fans of Neal Stephenson, John Barth and Thomas Pynchon will enjoy this; another reviewer compares Morrow to John Barth, and, in the past, he has been compared to writers such as Kurt Vonnegut and John Updike.

Most reviewers praise The Last Witchfinder for its humor and impeccable research. The comment below from the Washington Post is representative of many:

"James Morrow's novel about early American witchcraft pulls off so many dazzling feats of literary magic that in a different century he'd have been burned at the stake. Forget The Crucible, Arthur Miller's dreary classic. Forget the repugnant kitsch of modern-day Salem. The Last Witchfinder flies us back to that thrilling period when scientific rationalism was dropped into the great cauldron of intellectual history, boiling with prejudice, tradition, piety and fear. The result is a fantastical story mixed so cunningly with real-life details that your vision of America's past may never awaken from Morrow's spell."

However, not all reviews glow so positively, for example, Kirkus feels that while it is "commendably ambitious ... this intensely cerebral extravaganza doesn't really work."

If 'intensely cerebral extravaganzas' are your cup of tea, and you feel you can appreciate a tale of enlightenment and superstition (from which many might draw parallels with the modern day) then this might be for you - otherwise, proceed with caution!

Useful link: Those who have already read the book might enjoy "The Story in Brief" on James Morrow's website, which includes a pithy summary of the fictional plot alongside real contemporary illustrations.

This review was originally published in The BookBrowse Review in April 2006, and has been updated for the March 2007 edition. Click here to go to this issue.