I appreciated how the author, while weaving in the struggles and atrocities of war, developed such real characters and relationships that exist no matter the culture from kids defying their parents to dealing with aging parents and often dementia.
Created: 06/05/18
Replies: 17
Join Date: 01/26/17
Posts: 27
I appreciated how the author, while weaving in the struggles and atrocities of war, developed such real characters and relationships that exist no matter the culture from kids defying their parents to dealing with aging parents and often dementia.
Join Date: 06/05/18
Posts: 41
Although this novel covers a period of over 50 years which are dominated by war and conflict for this Palestinian family, the author is masterful in writing it as a single narrative. With each chapter focusing on an individual family member at a specific point in time, she presents the reader with enough detail to weave together the lives of three plus generations. It is a compelling story of memorable characters, unique settings and rich historical context. I look forward to reading whatever comes next for this talented young author.
Join Date: 06/29/15
Posts: 140
What stood out for me was when the family learned about Alia's Alzheimer's diagnosis and how each family member reacted and behaved. To me it was a shift in the story. It also showed how everyone learned to live with it. I think it stood out for me because my father had Alzheimer's.
Join Date: 06/05/18
Posts: 212
A couple of things stood out for me - first I had never really considered the Palestinian experience. That was an important take away for me. Second, I found significant universal truths in the book. I think if you were to give authors in different countries the family tree, personality types, points of conflict, and crucial moments information from this book and tell them to write a story from their own homeland, it would look somewhat similar. Mostly because we all have universal truths - people are pushed into things they don't want to do (Mustafa) which changes their lives dramatically, someone has lifelong guilt about something (Atef), there are difficult personalities in families (Alia and Souad), there is a stabilizing influence (Salma) and medical issues (Alia) and the children have their own difficulties based on environment and experience (Manar, Linah, and Zain).
Join Date: 02/05/16
Posts: 317
What stood out most for me is that as a American by birth, and able to trace my family history here back to the start, I have taken for granted how that much that contributes to my sense of belonging. Like the air that I breathe, it's just there... Yet for so many people in different parts of the world, including newcomers to the US, that sense of belonging is forever uprooted, and it has a devastating impact on them. This novel made me appreciate that.
I agree the author did an amazing job of making this a universal story but with distinct, individual characters, and weaving it all together over a considerable time span, taking on different narrative viewpoints without confusing or overwhelming the reader. It was engrossing and convincing every step of the way.
Join Date: 04/11/18
Posts: 10
Join Date: 08/16/17
Posts: 160
I think the depiction of how intensely personal world events can become was very important part of the novel. We often think we know about world events, but to follow a family, even a wealthy family, is very sobering. Many of the youngest generation became Americans, losing much of their separate Palestinian identity. Had they remained in Israel, other parts of the Arab world or even Europe they would be completely different people. The family has huge influence, but so does the country and culture the individuals live in.
Join Date: 02/18/15
Posts: 464
I think for me, the point that stood out was the strength of the women. No matter what the issues became, their petty arguments, their moves to different countries, their values, when it came down to each individual character it was their strength that stood out.
Join Date: 01/23/15
Posts: 214
Join Date: 06/13/11
Posts: 107
Join Date: 02/17/18
Posts: 17
This was an interesting family saga. The author gave us characters at different points in their lives, especially the children growing into adults. The reader could see how certain personality traits changed or evolved as the characters aged. This helped to move the story along. I am not convinced that the background political issues of displacement and war were totally integral to the story. They were almost tacked on. If the background was not the Middle East, it could have been Europe during and after World War II, or India after Partition, or any of many other 20th century disruptions. Possibly the background did not resonate with me because of the relative wealth of the family. They landed on their feet wherever they were even if it was not exactly where they wanted to be.
Join Date: 03/29/16
Posts: 344
Join Date: 05/29/15
Posts: 460
Join Date: 06/13/11
Posts: 70
The author wrote an amazing first book. We Americans know so little about the history and cultures of the Middle East. She interwove her experiences about various cities in the Middle East in an interesting, thought-provoking novel. Sagas of families reflect the different time periods, the many and continuing conflicts, and explanations in fictionalized form of what the characters felt and thought. I learned so very much unknown to me via Ms. Alyan's portrayal of her "Salt House".
Join Date: 09/02/13
Posts: 43
The ability of families, through 4 generations to stay together and in some way come to terms with each other and their changing circumstances in the midst of world events that c ontinued to tear their worlds and each other apart. They complained but somehow they managed to maintain the link that made them who they were and made them strong
Join Date: 06/25/18
Posts: 1
I am a big fan of intergenerational books so this fit my reading profile well. The author did a great job weaving the individual threads over so many years and in the context of ongoing Middle-eastern strife.
I have friends from that area and it reflected so much that I have come to know of their culture. I will pass my copy on to others in my own family.
Join Date: 09/15/14
Posts: 84
What stood out most for me was the use of a displaced Palestinian family as the protaganist(s) in this captivating novel. Although I am, of course, familiar with the Palestinian diaspora through reading and watching news it felt so different experiencing it through the characters in the book.
Join Date: 03/10/15
Posts: 45
Reply
Please login to post a response.