Despite having a young child, Greta and Adam still chose to take part in the Red Orchestra. Do you think you would have done the same?
Created: 02/27/20
Replies: 13
Join Date: 10/15/10
Posts: 3216
Join Date: 08/28/15
Posts: 15
Its hard to judge what one would do IF you were in their shoes. I admired all the courage of the people in the resistance, but think I would first think about my child and what would happen if I was not there to take care of them.
Join Date: 01/01/16
Posts: 393
Join Date: 01/22/18
Posts: 152
It is hard to imagine the world they were living in and therefore hard to know. I would like to believe that having a child would have made me brave enough to do what they did and everything I could to make the world better for my child.
Join Date: 02/28/20
Posts: 31
I think I might have if I was as committed to a cause as they were in the fight against fascism. Plus they both loved Germany and wanted it to be a better place for their son to grow up in.
Join Date: 08/01/16
Posts: 70
I am not sure that I would have had the courage they demonstrated. It is so difficult to imagine what you would do in someone else's shoes. The Red Orchestra was their vehicle to help overcome the reign of Hitler and, I guess, they felt they had no choice despite having a child
Join Date: 07/28/11
Posts: 384
Join Date: 10/12/11
Posts: 256
Join Date: 01/25/20
Posts: 13
Join Date: 06/05/18
Posts: 41
I have often asked myself how much risk I would have been willing to take if I had young children who were dependent on me for their safety and protection. I like to think that I would have been brave and certainly would not have endorsed antisemitism or other Nazi principles, but to actually engage in espionage and other types of activities I am not so sure. Perhaps it is impossible to know how one will react until we are faced with the situation.
Join Date: 08/16/17
Posts: 158
I hope I would have. Working toward the hope of a free Germany for their child was worth it. All those Germans who hid in the shadows to protect themselves is why the Nazis were able to take over. I don’t think we really know how we would act sitting here in 2020.
Join Date: 06/13/11
Posts: 272
It is hard to put myself in the position of a Greta and Adam. The fact that they had friends joiningbwith them did help I am sure. The support of their friends certainly helped.
Join Date: 02/11/20
Posts: 8
It's hard to put myself in someone else's shoes, especially when the time period and circumstances are so different. With that said though, I think I probably would not have done the same because I would feel that I owed it to my child to act responsibly in my capacity as his or her parent. Also, the guilt of possibly putting my child's life in danger (since no one can say for sure in that particular situation whether the Nazis would've spared the child) as well as having to burden my family to take care of him / her, I think those would be the main deterrents for me.
Join Date: 05/29/15
Posts: 460
Reply
Please login to post a response.