Please be aware that this discussion guide may contain spoilers!
Amina thinks, "Their courtship had more in common with her grandparents'which had been arranged through a professional matchmaker in their villagethan with her parents', who'd had a love marriage" (p. 28). Are there fundamental differences between finding a partner on the Internet and traditional matchmaking methods? What might make a traditional arranged marriage or one made online appealing to men and women in the twenty-first century?
What does Amina and George's online correspondence reveal about their respective personalities and expectations? In what ways are they well suited to each other despite their different backgrounds? What do their decisions to seek a spouse online indicate about their approaches to and ideas about marriage? How do their personal motivations influence the information they offerand hold back?
"In spite of all the preparation, there was something surprising about actually finding herself in Rochester, waiting for a green card in the mail" (pp. 78). What aspects of Amina's new life does she find puzzling, pleasing, or difficult to accept? Consider, for example, the dinner at George's mother's house (p. 18); the wedding preparations and ceremony (pp. 3840); and her various work experiences. What presents the greatest psychological challenges? What compromises does she make and why?
Spurred by "Amina's anxiety about the Muslim ceremony, without which they wouldn't really be married" (p. 34), the couple searches for an imam to marry them. Why does Amina decide against getting married at the Islamic Center of Rochester? What does the decision reflect about the role religion plays in her life? What does it convey about her complicated attachment to her past? How does she reconcile her decision with the promises she made to her parents?
"She struggled to find some connection between the girl she so often imagined at home in her parents' apartment and this American wife. . . . The task was made more difficult by the fact that there was no one in Rochester who'd known that past-Munni, and no one back at home who knew the present one" (p. 59). How does this passage capture the isolation and sense of displacement that is often part of the immigrant experience? Are there parallels between Amina's feelings and the feelings of any young wife (or husband) in the early years of marriage?
How would you characterize the friendship between Kim and Amina? What does each of them find appealing in the other? Is their relationship built on genuine affection or on false premises and selfish interests?
How do Kim's experiences in India (pp. 12226) and her life with Ashok in post-9/11 New York (p. 15155) relate to the themes of the novel? What do their stories reveal about the effects of cultural and religious prejudices on ordinary people? How do their ordeals compare to Amina's?
"She and George didn't disagree very often, but when they did it was always because of 'cultural differences'a phrase so useful in forestalling arguments that she felt sorry for those couples who couldn't employ it" (p. 66). To what extent are the problems or misunderstandings in their marriage attributable to "cultural differences"? What role do the emotional differences between them play?
Is Amina's search of Kim's apartment justifiable (pp. 14142)? Why doesn't she confront Kim directly? Are the conclusions Amina draws about George's family as clear-cut as she assumes (p. 143)? Is her observation, made in a moment of bitterness"You might cheat, steal, lie, but if you confessed, you could be instantly forgiven" (p. 147)a valid assessment of American behavior?
What impact does Amina's discovery about George's past have on the dynamics of their marriage? Does his explanation of his deception (pp. 14849) and his subsequent behavior (pp. 15657) change your feelings about him? In light of his confession, are Amina's demands reasonable, or do they amount to emotional blackmail? Consider her own interpretation: "What a strange thing, she thought, to find out one day that you had built your whole life on a mistake, and the next day to discover that this fact would allow you to have your dearest wish. She wondered if this was a unique predicament, something related to the unusual circumstances of her life, or a more general human condition" (p.156). Discuss your responses to this in terms of the novel and your own experiences.
When she arrives in Bangladesh, Amina thinks, "You thought you were the permanent part of your own experience, . . . until you discovered that there were many selves, dissolving into one another" (p. 207). Is Amina's experience unusual, or is this a common reaction to returning home after a long absence?
How does Freudenberger bring the atmosphere and social milieu of Bangladesh to life in the narrative? Which details best evoke the emotional pull Amina feels toward her homeland?
During a lighthearted flirtation with Nasir, Amina thinks of the past and realizes, "She had the same feelings, sweeter because they'd been dormant for so long, but her wish from that time had been granted: she was a grown woman, with everything she would need to attract a man like Nasir" (pp. 25051). Why are she and Nasir so drawn to each other? What part does nostalgia, the comfort of the familiar, and the loneliness they experiencedNasir in London, Amina in Americahave in the awakening of their feelings? What do you think would have happened had she chosen to pursue Nasir instead of returning home to George?
How do their families' examples, opinions, and advice shape Amina and George's relationship? Compare the influences of various family members (Amina's parents and extended family in Bangladesh; George's mother, Eileen Stillman, and his aunt Cathy and cousin Jessica). What does the novel show about the qualities, good and bad, shared by families from every culture or country?
Freudenberger often moves from a scene in Rochester to a past event or conversation in Dhaka. How does this affect the flow of the plot? What does it contribute to your understanding of Amina and the forces and feelings that have shaped her?
"She had escaped a broken country, and George a broken heart; they had chosen each other in spite of warnings from both sides. . . . Even if neither of their motives had been pure, wasn't it possible that something pure had come of them now?" (pp. 17475). Does Amina and George's commitment to each other ever evolve into genuine love? Cite specific moments in the novel to support your point of view.
Freudenberger ends the novel with a twist: Amina's "Reach for the Stars" essay, which has actually been composed by Kim for a writing competition sponsored by Starbucks. As Mohsin Hamid noted in his front-cover review of The Newlyweds in The New York Times Book Review (April 29, 2012), this essay has a certain parallel to Freudenberger's own role as authorand it poses a larger question about authenticity and storytelling. What pitfalls might Freudenberger have faced, if any, in writing Amina's story? Do you agree with Hamid's statement that, for fiction "the question of authenticity . . . is a red herring: nationalities, ethnicities, genders and even species do not 'own' the right to fictional narratives spoken in what purport to be their voices"? To what extent is Amina in her new American life crafting a persona different from the "authentic" self she knew at home?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Vintage.
Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.
A Man Called Intrepid author dies aged 89(Dec 03 2013) William Stevenson, a journalist and author who drew on his close ties with intelligence sources to write two best-selling books in the 1970s, A Man Called...