It's a bad time to be a boy in America. As the century drew to a close, the defining event for American girls was the triumph of the U.S. women's soccer team. For boys, the symbolic event was the mass killing at Columbine High School.
It would seem that boys in our society are greatly at risk. Yet the best-known studies and the academic experts say that it's girls who are suffering from a decline in self-esteem. It's girls, they say, who need extra help in school and elsewhere in a society that favors boys. The problem with boys is that they are boys, say the experts. We need to change their nature. We have to make them more like...girls.
These arguments don't hold up to scrutiny, says Christina Hoff Sommers in this provocative, fascinating book. She analyzes the work of the leading academic experts, Carol Gilligan and William Pollack, and finds it lacking in scientific rigor. There is no girl crisis, says Sommers. Girls are outperforming boys academically, and girls' self-esteem is no different from boys'. Boys lag behind girls in reading and writing ability, and they are less likely to go to college.
The "girl crisis" has been seized upon by some feminists and has been suffused with sexual politics. Under the guise of helping girls, many schools have adopted policies that penalize boys, often for simply being masculine. Sommers says that boys do need help, but not the sort they've been getting. They need help catching up with girls academically. They need love, discipline, respect, and moral guidance. They desperately need understanding. They do not need to be rescued from masculinity.
Booklist - Mary Carroll
Sommers argues cogently that boys are having major problems in school that must be addressed, but she may not convince all readers these problems are caused by the American Association of University Women, Carol Gilligan, Mary Pipher, and William Pollack. Her analysis of research on girls' adolescent loss of self-esteem reveals empirical inadequacies, and most readers will probably agree that some feminist teaching approaches are pretty silly. Ultimately, however, Sommers is as much of a crisismonger as those she critiques. It's a centuries-long struggle reformers who seek a different approach to gender socialization expect schools to help improve society; Sommers wants them to teach kids how to fit into the society we already have. In place of the feminists' Rousseauian philosophy of ethical romanticism, Sommers prescribes directive moral or character education, instilling a sense of responsibility and civility in all children, but particularly boys.
A sharp study that raises troubling questions about the integrity of the research underlying much current educational polemic--and the policies that these polemics have inspired
Recent Reader Reviews
Rated of 5
by Mr. Ali Saberi
This is Ali , an English teacher in Iran . I guess Dr . Sommer's book is defending boys from being labled as the " second sex ".
Rated of 5
If you have a son or sons, this book will coalesce your feelings and provide moral support. For every meeting where your son's teacher explains patiently that he is not meeting his potential, you can ask the appropriate questions about the material... Read More
Rated of 5
This book shows how what's really going on with our young people, especially boys. It has firm facts to dissprove any and all critics, and shows some of the awful things that are being done to our young men, along with solutions that are proven to... Read More
Rated of 5
It took everything in my power to read this book. Sommers opinions are all partial and not interesting.
A Man Called Intrepid author dies aged 89(Dec 03 2013) William Stevenson, a journalist and author who drew on his close ties with intelligence sources to write two best-selling books in the 1970s, A Man Called...