Please be aware that this discussion guide may contain spoilers!
What does incorrigible mean? Do you think
Alexander, Beowulf, and Cassiopeia really are
incorrigible? Could any of the other characters
in the novel be described as incorrigible?
The narrator says that Penelope Lumley is "perfectly match[ed]" to "what any reasonable person might expect a young governess to look like" (p. 7). What adjectives would you use to describe Penelope?
When Penelope first tells the story of the ponies, she says that Silky's rough behavior is not his fault because he has "known no kindness or tender care in his life" (p. 40). Do you agree or disagree? Are people and animals responsible for acting badly if they've never been taught to act in a better way?
Penelope insists that "children should sleep in
beds, in clean pajamas, and have bedtime books read aloud" (p. 52). What other things do you
think children need?
Consider how Lord Fredrick claims ownership of the Incorrigibles after finding them on his property. Should the rule Lord Fredrick calls "finders keepers" pertain to all situations (p. 53)? If yes, why? If no, in which situations might it not apply?
Describe Lady Constance. By the end of the story, do you feel any pity or compassion for her? Why
or why not?
Despite being absent for most of the novel, Lord Fredrick has some key scenes and makes some key decisions. What do you know about Lord Fredrick from the text? What do you suspect about him?
What is foreshadowing? How does the narrator
use foreshadowing both to build suspense and
to alleviate tension?
How does the author incorporate humor into the story? Which scene or line from the book do you think is the funniest?
Penelope explains irony to the Incorrigibles as "when you say one thing but mean something else .... or when you expect things to happen one way and then they turn out quite differently" (p. 153). Based on this definition, can you find three
examples of irony in the novel? How does
the author use irony as a form of humor?
The narrator defines hyperbole as the "practice of overstating the case" (p. 188). Find an example of hyperbole in the book, and explain why you think the subject of your example is being exaggerated. Is it for humor, emphasis, dramatic effect, or
Penelope buys books as presents, and she carefully tries to pick out the perfect book for each person on her list (pp. 153154). Make a list of five of your family members or friends. If you could give each of them the perfect book, what would you choose? Explain your selections.
Famous literary governesses and teachers include Amelia Bedelia, Albus Dumbledore, Jane Eyre,
Ms. Frizzle, Nurse Matilda, Merlin, and Mary Poppins. What qualities does Penelope Lumley share with these teaching colleagues? How is she unique?
What other stories about orphans have you read? Consider Anne of Green Gables, the Boxcar Children books, The Graveyard Book, the Harry Potter series, Oliver Twist, The Secret Garden , and A Series of Unfortunate Events. How are other orphan
stories similar to and different from The Incorrigible Children of Ashton Place? Why do you think stories about orphans are appealing to young readers?
What is a mystery? What mysteries are introduced in the book? Which of these mysteries are solved during the course of the narrative and which
remain unsolved? Do you have any suspicions about how some of the unresolved mysteries
might play out in later books in the series?
Tableau Vivant. Lady Constance has high hopes for her tableau vivant but has to call the thespians offstage when the only stories they show are about wolves. The Incorrigibles try to help by making
their own tableau for The Wreck of the Hesperus.
Now it's your turn! Choose a scene or event from
the novel and plan a tableau. Which characters will you show? How will they stand? What will they wear? What props will you use to make your staging realistic? Present your tableau to the class and see
if your peers can guess which part of the story
Agatha Swanburne's Famous Sayings. Compile a
list of Ms. Swanburne's sayings. Then look up often-quoted sayings by famous writers and thinkers,
such as Confucius, Benjamin Franklin, Dorothy Parker, William Shakespeare, or Mark Twain. Create
an advice book for grown-ups by combining
Ms. Swanburne's sayings with some famous ones that you especially like. Can you create your own succinct, no-nonsense maxims to help adults be
better behaved and better solve their problems?
Add your original sayings to your book.
Not Just Bum-De-Bum-De-Bum-De-Bum. Penelope is impressed with the poems created by the Incorrigibles. Create your own hilarious, Incorrigible-inspired poem, incorporating questions and
exclamations, repetition, rhyme, or sound effects.
Performance Reading. Whether it's the tale of
Rainbow and Silky or The Wreck of the Hesperus, it's clear that Penelope loves reading aloud. Choose a short piece of writing (from this book or another) that you'd like to polish to perfection and practice reading it aloud. For whom will you perform your selection? What reactions do you want your audience to have as you're reading? How can the way in which you read bring about the reactions that you want? How will you know if you're telling a good story?
Illustrated Captions. Jon Klassen's illustrations
charmingly complement Maryrose Wood's words in The Incorrigible Children of Ashton Place. Choose a
line from the story to serve as your caption (one that Mr. Klassen hasn't already depicted) and create your own accompanying illustration. Possible lines to
illustrate include: "Ashton Place was a very grand house indeed" (p. 16), "the light from Mrs. Clarke's candle entered a step before the woman herself "
(p. 127), "they spent the journey looking
wide-eyed out the carriage windows" (p. 149),
or "Lady Constance let out another snore, which
everyone politely ignored" (p. 205).
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Balzer + Bray.
Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.
Research shows that 90% of Americans value public libraries(Dec 11 2013) According to a survey by the Pew Research Center, about 90% of Americans aged 16 and older said that the closing of their local public library would have an...