Meg Rosoff discusses her second novel Just in Case
Q. How were you able to get into the mind of a teenage boy? How did it feel
to write from a perspective so distant from your own? Justin reminded one reader
of Holden Caulfield. Are there any other characters in literature to whom you
think Justin compares, or who inspired your creation of Justin?
A: I think I'm something of a chameleon at heart, because I don't have any
trouble getting into the brain of a teenage boy. Of course there are plenty of
teenage boys I couldn't begin to understand, but Justin isn't exactly macho, or
even particularly male. I've always thought of a long horizontal "gender line,"
with really macho male men way over on the left, and really feminine, girly
girls way over on the right. And because I was always a tomboy and never thought
of myself as particularly girly, I imagine myself as fairly near the center of
the line. So crossing over it and writing from a male point of view isn't that
hard for me. Though I don't think I could get inside Arnold Schwarzenegger's
I don't know about another character in literature like Justinthere's a lot
of me in him, though I was never quite as loopy as he is. But I remember
distinctly the feeling that I didn't know exactly where the edges of reality
were, not only when I was a teenager, but for many years afterwards, especially
when it came to things like attraction and sexual relationships and how the
world worked. The rules of the world seemed so unclear to me, and I wanted to
write a book about a character who wasn't sure where reality began and ended.
Q. Readers have debated whether Justin is seriously depressed, or if he is
merely a victim of Fate's exhausting games. Perhaps one condition led to the
other. How did you intend for us to see Justin?
A: I was careful not to paint Justin as a psychopath, though some people do
see him that way. At one point I asked my older sister (who's a shrink) to read
the rough draft and tell me whether she thought he sounded too crazy (she said
no). Justin is depressed, but he's not crazy. In other words, he's a teenager,
not a schizophrenic, and he has a tendency to see the dark underside of life a
lot more clearly than the cheerful side. This makes him much more susceptible to
Fate's games. I remember years ago having a friend who was very depressed, and
he said to me, "I see the world much more accurately than non-depressed people
do, it's just that it's not a very productive way of looking at life." And of
course, he was right in many ways. Justin has a moment early in the book in
which it suddenly occurs to him how dangerous life really is, how many truly
awful things could happen, how vulnerable he is. And though his response to that
realization is somewhat extreme, he is in fact right . Life is dangerous and
terrifying and full of loss and tragedy, and most of us manage to get through it
and stay cheerful by pretending it will all turn out alright. That makes me
sound like a real pessimist, but I'm not. I do believe that terrible sadness is
part of life, and in the end, we all die, so there are no permanent happy
endings. But like Charlie, I also think "something nice might happen" along the
Q: The format of Just in Casenotably the inclusion of Fate's commentaryis
quite unique. (This novel certainly demands close reading!) Why did you choose
to present the story in this way? Some readers suggest that the complicated,
back-and-forth format serves to play games on readers, just as Fate plays games
on Justin. How would you respond?
A: The readers who suggested that the back-and-forth format was a reflection
of Fate's game-playing with Justin can go to the head of the class! One of my
editors asked me (before the book was published) whether Fate was all in
Justin's head, or whether he was a real external character, and my answer was "Yes." In other words, both. I'm very interested in what I call
"the edges of
reality"the places where fact and fantasy meet. They're the places that things
like superstitious behavior emerge from, or a belief in luck, or religion. I
don't believe that Fate as a character controls our lives, but you won't catch
me walking under a ladder, either.
Q: We're glad Justin has Peter as a friend throughout his whole ordeal. How
come Peter believes Justin so easily? Justin's relationship with Agnes, on the
other hand, is a bit rockier. How did you come up with her character?
A: I had an idea when I started the book that I wanted to surround Justin
with people who just naturally were able to see the world more clearly than he
did. Even his dog and his baby brother understand more about how the world
works. Dorothea says at one point: "Don't apologizeyou don't choose to be this
way." She knows he has a very complicated and pessimistic world view, but she
doesn't blame him or dislike him for it. The affection and tolerance of his
friends is one of the things that saves him. I've been asked how Peter can see
Justin's invisible dog, but doesn't real friendship often involve a powerful
shared world view? I remember sitting in a theater once where everyone was
hysterical laughing, and my friend and I sat there stony-faced. We felt like
Martians, like we were the only two people who didn't think the joke was funny.
As for Agnes, she's simpleI consciously wanted to create a relationship that
was wrong, but without actually blaming either party. Most bad relationships in
books or films rely on one of the partners being a villain. But Agnes isn't a
villain, her intentions with Justin are good, they're just wrong! I suppose
that's why she can't see his dog. She doesn't share his vision of the world the
way Dorothea and Peter and Charlie do.
Q: To what extent did you intend for readers to take the "metaphysical"
components of Just in Case seriously? For instance, is Charlie truly brilliant
and psychic, or is he just a figment of Justin's imagination?
A: Ah . . . that's the wonderful thing about fiction. The writer doesn't take
a photograph of the real world, he/she is making up stories. I have occasionally
met a very tiny baby who strikes me as weirdly wise and possibly thinking very
deep thoughts. But what's important about Charlie is that even as a baby, he can
make more sense of the world than Justin can. He says "Duck" and someone hands
him a duck. Justin would stare at a duck for hours, and then say "Pizza" and
wonder why no one understood what he wanted. So whether Charlie is a genius or
not, he has something very important to teach Justin.
Q: Justin's imaginary dog, Boy, is fascinating. How did you come up with the
idea for Boy? Why is it that some people can see Boy, while others are
A: Boy just leapt into my head (like a greyhound!) one day, though I suspect
he's based on the imaginary dogs and horses I had as a child. I loved animals so
much and wanted a dog or a horse so badly, that I made them up, and they seemed
very real to me. I don't know why he had to be a greyhound, as I've never known
a greyhound in real life, but he just did. Characters are like that sometimes,
they wander into your story and you get stuck with them.
In the book, the people who can see Boy are the people who have managed to
tune into Justin's wavelength, who have understanding and sympathy for the way
he views the world, who are open to a wide variety of experiences and are not so
black and white themselves.
As an aside, I fell so in love with the character of Boy, that I bought two
part greyhound puppies. And you'll be astonished to hear that they are not wise
and serene, at least not when they're eating their way through all the shoes and
furniture in the house. (But I do love them madly.)
Q: What is Dorothea's purpose in the book? It's interesting how she adamantly
defends "Nature's way" in Chapter 37. How is she related to Fate?
A: Dorothea is the anti-sentimentalist in the book. She accepts events and
people for what they are and isn't shocked by them. I'm not sure how she's
related to Fate, but don't you get the feeling that Fate wouldn't dream of
messing with Dorothea? I don't thinks she'd make a good plaything, she's too
strong and self-possessed.
Q: How did you choose the ending for Just in Case? Was it something you
envisioned from the beginning, or did it evolve as your writing progressed?
A: From the very beginning, I knew I wanted Justin to have to fight a real
one-on-one, life-and-death battle with Fate at the end, to decide who was
stronger. I wanted Justin to have to choose to live, despite his understanding
of the risks. And he does.
Q: In the book, Fate has a lot of control over what the characters do and
say. As the author of the book, you have similar control over what the
characters do and say. Did you see yourself as Fate in the lives of these
A: That's a wonderful question, and it surprises me greatly to say that for
me, the answer is no. Once I create characters, I almost feel as if they have a
life of their own, and I'm just responsible for writing down their story. I
never feel as if I'm manipulating them, though of course I am. The process of
writing feels much more like trying to find out what their story is, and
reporting it accurately and compellingly. Weird, but true.
Q: Why did you choose to give Fate a voice? At the very beginning of
Case, Fate discloses that he/she is "up here." Where are you referring to? Do
you believe in fate? Do you think fate is as conniving as you represent it in
Just in Case?
A: I don't believe in fate, per se, but I do believe that life is a
minefieldand if you add a little bit of depression and a little bit of paranoia
to the mix, you can start to believe that someone or something is planning your
downfall. Giving Fate a voice just snapped that "force" into focus, so that it
no longer felt random, but controlled. When my youngest sister was very ill with
cancer, I noticed that my family (who had always been very rational) became very
superstitious, and I thought, "Aha!" Depression drives people to look for
reasons, and to look for ways to control the outcome (see also: religion). My
middle sister also had cancer, and she said at one point that every time she
picked up a penny off the street, she "believed" it gave her an extra week of
life. Now, she knew rationally that this wasn't true, but she did it
nonetheless. And so did we all. My whole family was picking pennies up for
As for "up here," I wasn't thinking of heaven, but a kind of Google-earth
perspective on humanityenough height to give an overview that humans usually
Q: What inspired you to write Just in Case? How and where do you do your best
writing? What types of books do you like to read most? Who are some of your
A: I've always been a little bit obsessed by the idea of "what if?"the times
you turn left instead of right and it changes your whole life. When my daughter
was a baby, I turned around to lock the front door and she went down the steps
in her stroller and slammed face down on the sidewalk, and though she was fine
in the end, I was depressed for months afterwards, thinking that in that one
moment of inattention I could have killed her. I heard an interview with a woman
years ago, whose son fell off a roof and died and she said that for the next 50
years she relived that moment over and over, if only she'd reached out a few
seconds earlier. And what about the guy who went out drinking the night before
9/11 and overslept the next morning and didn't get to work on time, and it saved
his life? In moments like that, fate feels like a very strong presence.
I do my best writing in a little house I bought with a friend on the beach in
Suffolk. There's no television, radio, telephone, or Internet there, and
occasionally I run away and leave my family and just make a fire and take the
dogs and work 12 hours a day. It's bliss. The rest of the time I'm like any
other urban motherI get my daughter to school, clear off the kitchen table,
make the beds, answer the e-mails, talk to my husband, walk the dogs, and try to
work in-between! It can be frustrating, but ideas all come out of the richness
I'm a very promiscuous readerI love to read about 19th- and
early-20th-century explorers and travel writers (Isabella Bird, Wilfred Thesiger, Thor Heyerdahl), mid-20th century Virago fictionwritten by women,
usually about domestic life (Elizabeth Taylor, Rosalind Lehmann, Molly
Keane)and I'm not very good at nonfiction or biography, despite being
obsessively interested in people. When I was a teenager I read Hemingway,
Dostoevsky, Ian Fleming, and now I love being surprised with quirky storiesI
adored Andrey Kurkov's Death of a Penguinbut then I really like Alice Munroe
and Philip Roth who both write about "ordinary life." Oh, and good graphic
novelsArt Spiegelman's Maus is amazing. As for teen books, a few of my
favorites this year are Siobhan Dowd's A Swift Pure Cry, and Frances Hardinge's
Fly by Night. And Andreas Steinhoefel's The Centre of the World. Doesn't narrow
it down much, does it?
Q: Finally, one of the participating book groups attends a school with an
active speech team. Is there one passage, in particular, from Just in Case that
you think would be enhanced by a live dramatic interpretation?
A: Well, a bit of dialogue might help . . . maybe Chapter 28 or 33two
encounters between Agnes and Justin during which he tries to explain his panic
to her and she tries to reassure him. I like them because they give an idea of
how two people experiencing the same event can view it in such totally different
Reproduced with the permission of Random House. Thanks to the following Teen Book Groups for participating!
Beech Grove High School Book Group, Beech Grove, Indiana
Cypress Creek High School Bears Book Club, Orlando, Florida
St. Monica School Teen Zone Book Club, Mercer Island, Washington
Meg Rosoff discusses the inspiration for her first novel,
How I Live Now
What was the inspiration for your book, How I Live Now?
I wrote the book in the run-up to the Iraq war, when no one I knew could
quite believe that we were going to war based on what appeared, even then, to be
a fairly thin proposition. Many of us had a sense that America and the UK's
aggressive stance was creating more enemies abroad by the minute, and that
instead of an end to terrorism, we were on the verge of starting something
horrific - something that might go on for years. It was in that frame of mind
that I began writing -- in an atmosphere of paranoia and dread about the future.
Who do you hope will read the book?
Although I wrote the book with teenagers in mind, it seems to have found an
audience I didn't quite expect. I had a letter recently from a man in his 70s
who was evacuated from London during WW2, who said the book brought back his
experiences of that war with great clarity. I've also heard from children as
young as nine or ten, who say they loved the book, and were very moved by the
issues raised in it. It seems to be finding its own audience in all sorts of
different age groups, perhaps because it explores a series of universal themes
(love, loyalty, growing up, war, loss) that apply to all ages.
What do you hope readers will take out of it?
It's hard to predict what readers will take out of a book, but I'd particularly
hope that my teenage readers come away with a sense of the importance and
redemptive power of love, friendship, emotional connections and loyalty, and the
horror of war. Not a lot to ask for!
Some reviewers have expressed concern over the relationship between the
two first cousins. Why did you choose to write about a relationship between
first cousins, that although legal across Europe and most of the USA, some might
Daisy and Edmond are cousins, but grew up without ever meeting each other.
Those ties often prove to be very powerful emotionally when they are finally
realized. But ultimately, I suppose, I didn't want any of my characters to fall
into easy and familiar roles that people would take for granted as acceptable.
Daisy is young, angry, and desperate for a connection that will help heal her
damaged sense of self. The powerful connections she discovers with Edmond and
Piper, her love for them and her sense of responsibility towards them, helps her
to save herself as well as them.
You have a young daughter, how do you think she would react if she was in
Daisy's place? How do you think today's youth in general would react to such a
I hope I've brought my daughter up to protect and care for other people, and
she's a strong-minded character with a powerful sense of justice. I think people
often behave with great courage when the situation requires it -- you just never
know how you might react until tested.
Your novel outlines a very credible scenario for how a country such as
England could be 'taken hostage'. Did you do background reading to come up with
the idea, or is it totally from your imagination?
A little of both. I've read quite a bit about England during WWI, and WW2 is
still present in daily life: I have a wonderful 85-year-old neighbor who lived
through London during the blitz as a young woman married to a baker. Some
of the details of life in England during the war are incredibly evocative, for
instance all the signposts in rural areas were removed, so an enemy landing in
the middle of the English countryside would have no idea where he was. Most
fiction seems to emerge from a combination of what the writer already knows, and
what he/she imagines.
What are you working on now?
I'm currently finishing the screenplay for How I Live Now, and
working on a second novel.
Do you plan to continue writing books for teens?
I like writing for and about teens because it's a very extreme time of life, and
that makes for intense transformations, intense possibilities for growth.
I think many people find their teens a difficult and disturbing time, but also a
time of great excitement and intensity. As a writer, you can't ask for a better
set-up than that.