Book Talk Home | Search Book Talk | Login | RSS
Not Logged in.
Book Jacket
Cartwheel
"Cartwheel will upend you; rarely does a novel this engaging ring so...
More about this book
Author Biography

Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

Created: 09/18/13

Replies: 8

Posted Sep. 18, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
admin

Join Date: 10/11/10

Posts: 369

Expert

Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?


Posted Sep. 30, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
janeh

Join Date: 06/15/11

Posts: 102

Expert

RE: Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

Eduardo's musings were pretty compelling at times, but I never swayed over to his point of view because I thought he attached the wrong meanings to small gestures.


Posted Sep. 30, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
bonnieb

Join Date: 09/11/11

Posts: 95

Expert

RE: Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

Though Eduardo was an ethical man, he believed Lily was guilty in his gut, not for any truly logical reason.


Posted Sep. 30, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
michellen

Join Date: 09/30/13

Posts: 3

RE: Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

Although we never learn exactly what happened that night, I was left with the impression that Lily was an accomplice - she didn't quite realize what was going on until it was too late


Posted Sep. 30, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
Erin G

Join Date: 05/24/12

Posts: 41

RE: Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

I think Eduardo had problems of his own that colored everything he saw. He believes himself to be a pure figure, fighting for justice even when it would be more convenient to tell a story that focused on Ignacio and write out Lily's alleged role. In reality, I think he believed in his own intuitive abilities and gave them priority over the actual evidence. He felt that Lily was a sociopath, he depicted her as a sociopath in the courtroom, and her own inability to act normal enough to suit other people convinced the court that maybe he was right.


Posted Oct. 05, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
beverlyj

Join Date: 12/22/11

Posts: 33

RE: Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

I too agree that Eduardo had some deep rooted problems that affected how he saw things. In many ways Eduardo hid these feelings from himself and others behind being able to convince others that his findings were the correct ones.
I also thought that Eduardo went after Lily like he did because she was an American and a woman - that was always nagging at the back of my mind when he was narrating. I though it was interesting that his wife's name was Maria (Mary in English) and some of his righteous stemmed from his believing in Maria's purity (which she herself will challenge him to acknowledge).


Posted Oct. 06, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
alisonf

Join Date: 01/31/13

Posts: 39

RE: Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

I cannot forgive Eduardo for the tactics he used with all the witnesses and the defendant. He felt he was clever and would lead everyone to providing what he needed not to get to the truth but to get to the outcome that he believed was right. I don't know how she could understand what she did was wrong when he wove his own version of the events that were not necessarily the truth. He didn't want her free and I think their was some anger at her as a female and American. If his job was to bring to light the crime then I think he drastically failed.


Posted Oct. 08, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
bobbie7

Join Date: 09/19/13

Posts: 19

RE: Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

I viewed Edwardo as a Javert in Les Mis. He was going to get his man (woman) at all costs because he believed it was his duty. I also wondered if he was a little infatuated with Lily


Posted Oct. 08, 2013 Go to Top | Bottom | link | alert
mariannes

Join Date: 12/17/12

Posts: 155

Expert

RE: Eduardo, attorney for the prosecution, believed Lily was guilty but that she didn't understand why what she did was wrong. Do you agree?

No, I don't agree with Eduardo. If Lily were guilty of murder, she would certainly know it was wrong. It doesn't make any sense for him to believe that. If Lily didn't know the difference between right and wrong, she would have done other wrong things before. Her sister said she did bad things, but her only example was that Lily enjoyed killing a slug when she was four. Since she didn't give any other examples, I discounted what she said.


Reply

Please login to post a response.