BookBrowse Reviews Eating Animals by Jonathan Safran Foer

BookBrowse:

The author of Everything is Illuminated presents an unflinching look at factory farming, and an impassioned argument for compassionate eating

I love sushi, I love fried chicken, I love a good steak. But there is a limit to my love. - Jonathan Safran Foer

Eating Animals is, at times, an emotionally tough read. It describes the miserable lives and often horrible deaths of poultry, cows, pigs and fish that are bred (or caught) for human consumption. You may want smelling salts for some of the passages that describe what happens to the animals that aren't yet dead when they get near the end of the conveyor. Nevertheless, this is a book that everyone should read, vegetarian or not. It is didactic without being dull, it presents its arguments without preaching, it manages to be both approachable in style and appealing to educated readers, and it offers up new arguments in addition to some familiar ones.

One of the elements that sets Foer's book apart from others in this genre is that he begins and ends with what he calls "Storytelling." The first chapter reminisces lovingly about his grandmother's cooking, and explains her relationship with food, which was shaped in part by her experiences as a young Jew in Europe during WWII. (She keeps kosher, but is not a vegetarian). After talking about his grandmother, Foer briefly describes his path to a vegetarian lifestyle, which didn't begin in earnest until after his son was born. It was at that point that he truly realized, "food matters." And so he began an exploration into how his food winds up on his plate. That journey resulted in this book, and, for Foer, a metaphorical new story in his life as a committed vegetarian. By using the metaphor and the device of "storytelling" as the framework of the book, Foer allows readers to accompany him on his journey. This means sharing his moments of resoluteness, guilt, ambivalence, anger, and love (of food, family, sharing) that punctuate the book.

For me, one of the issues of ethical vegetarianism that has always been problematic is the feeling that my efforts just won't matter. Just because I choose not have chicken for dinner, what ripple effect, if any, will that have on the poultry industry? Foer, to his credit, honestly admits that he cannot subscribe to "that quaint notion that everyone can make a difference." But our choices, he says, do influence others, because most people don't eat in isolation. Although he calls vegetarianism a personal choice, Foer also finds the idea of sharing one's knowledge (about where meat comes from) valuable.

Foer never tries to argue that animals are equal to humans. His focus is the pain and suffering caused by factory farms. He believes that animals do deserve a reasonably comfortable existence that does not include living in a cage too small to turn around in, or being forced to give birth to litter after litter of young, and a death that does not include being boiled alive, beaten to death, or sadistically tortured. Since these things happen at factory farms despite humane efforts, Foer feels that the ethical course is to stop consuming their products.

The argument that struck me as the one Foer really wants to make doesn't appear until close to the end of the book. He says, simply, that we do not need to eat animals to survive, and since animals raised and killed for our consumption do suffer (as he has shown by this point in the book), we should not eat them. Furthermore, meat and fish may taste good to us, but we human beings are evolved and intelligent enough to make choices about what we eat that go beyond just what "tastes good." We can choose to eat other things because we know that it's the right thing to do.

The book comes full circle in its final chapter, also called "Storytelling." It focuses on the Thanksgiving turkey, and reveals how difficult Foer himself finds it to let go of the sort of Thanksgiving (with the turkey as its centerpiece) that he remembers from his childhood. Yet, after consideration, he realizes that it is not the turkey that is important at the Thanksgiving meal, but the people around the table. And, he says, making a moral decision not to support factory farming is of greater importance to him than continuing the turkey-eating part of the tradition. Perhaps Foer's vision is idealistic, but it is hopeful. And one of the loveliest qualities of Eating Animals is its hopefulness, not just for animals but for human beings as well.

One other mention: you will be missing out if you ignore the 60 pages of notes and references at the end of the book. They provide interesting, additional information that's not included in the main text. If you find it too disruptive to flip back and forth as you read, try skimming through them after you have finished. The book even has an alphabetized index in the back.

This review was originally published in The BookBrowse Review in January 2010, and has been updated for the October 2010 edition. Click here to go to this issue.

This review is available to non-members for a limited time. For full access become a member today.