Please be aware that this discussion guide may contain spoilers!
Discuss the sibling relationships in the novel. To what extent have Noelles decisions been shaped by being Clarissa and Lilys sister?
When Marilyn announces that she and David are separating, Clarissa, Lily, and Noelle are thrown into shock. Is separation/divorce different for children when theyre adults than when theyre younger?
Marilyn wont let David tell the girls their news before everyone gets up to the Berkshires. Do you agree with this decision not to tell the family in advance?
Its been the hardest year of Thisbes life, yet its different for her. Marilyn and David were Leos parents. What does the novel mean by this? In what ways is it different to lose a son than to lose a husband?
Marilyn thinks, Mothers and daughters-in-law: such volatile, loaded relationships. Is there something about Marilyn and Thisbe that makes it hard for them to be close? Is the relationship between mother-in-law and daughter-in-law inherently volatile?
Clarissas infertility plays a central role in the book. Originally, it was Nathaniel who wanted to have children and Clarissa didnt, but now that theyre having trouble conceiving Clarissa seems more upset than Nathaniel is. Does this have to do with Leos death? Is infertility always harder for the woman than for the man?
Lily and Noelle have a particularly difficult relationship. Why is this? How do sibling relationships change as people get older? Are some siblings simply not meant to get along?
Marilyn and David bought kosher food and a new set of dishes so Noelle could eat in their home, but Noelle still wont eat there. Do you agree with Noelles decision? In a conflict between loyalty to ones family and loyalty to ones beliefs, what should win out?
There are some very high-powered people in this novel. Nathaniel has two PhDs and may someday win the Nobel Prize. Lily clerked on the Supreme Court. Malcolm is a chef featured in magazines. Marilyn is a successful doctor. Amram and Noelle, by contrast, struggle professionally. To what extent do the characters in this book define their own success in comparison with the success of their siblings and parents?
Thisbe says to Lily, Everyone who knew us says Leo and I were great together. Theres no love like the love thats been erased. Were Leo and Thisbe great together? How reliable is memory when someone has died? Do you think Thisbe and Leo would have worked things out if he had come home from Iraq?
Most of the major characters in the novel are female, yet the author is male. Does that influence the way you read this novel? Is it different for a male writer to write from the perspective of a woman?
Like the journalist Daniel Pearl, Leo was captured in the Middle East and executed by terrorists. More recently, a number of prominent journalists have died in the Middle East. The specter of the Iraq War hovers over this novel, and the book is populated by characters who have strong, often opposing political opinions. Yet the book takes place in the bucolic Berkshires, far from the center of the conflict. Would you describe this as a political novel?
Although Lily and Malcolm arent married, they live together and have been a couple for ten years. Why does Lily refuse to let Malcolm come to the Berkshires for Leos memorial? Does it say something about their relationship? About Lily herself?
Noelle thanks her father for being the voice that understands there are things you cant know. What does she mean by that? What makes David such a likable character?
Amram, by contrast, is a more difficult human being. What do you think attracted Noelle to him? What attracted Amram to Noelle? The novel says that Thisbe understands Amrams appeal. He has a kind of bullying charisma. Do you find Amram likable?
Judaism, Lily likes to say: just another installment in the random life of Noelle Glucksman. Later, Noelle tells Thisbe that it was random that she ended up in Israel and that she could just as easily have landed in Sweden. What role do randomness and coincidence play in Noelles life? In the lives of the other characters?
Thisbe thinks: Everyone wants to know about the milestonesLeos birthday, their anniversaryand those are hard, of course, but its the everyday things that are the toughest. What does Thisbe mean by that? Do you agree with her observation?
Gretchens wealth plays a role in this novel, and the family all responds to it differently. Discuss the role of money in the novel in general.
The book says that David mourns for Leo no less than Marilyn does even if he isnt bellowing it into bullhorns . . . In a way he thinks his response is more dignified. Is Davids response more dignified? Are there better and worse ways to mourn?
When Amram finally returns after having been gone for two days, Noelle is livid. Later, she hits Amram in the eye with a tennis ball, and Amram accuses her of having done so intentionally. Do you think Noelle hit him intentionally? Whom do you sympathize with in this scene?
At the books end, where do you think the various characters will be in ten years?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Vintage.
Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.
A Man Called Intrepid author dies aged 89(Dec 03 2013) William Stevenson, a journalist and author who drew on his close ties with intelligence sources to write two best-selling books in the 1970s, A Man Called...