Reading Guide Questions
Please be aware that this discussion guide may contain spoilers!
About This Book
A family epic, a love story, and a fascinating new image of America at the dawn
of the twentieth century, Vita
conveys a lost world that sparks the
imagination as well as the heart. Just as the novel's characters unlock one
another's secrets, readers will find much to discover and discuss in each
captivating chapter. This guide is designed to enhance the experience of reading
groups and individuals in exploring Vita
. We hope that the following
questions will enrich your reading of Melania G. Mazzucco's extraordinary novel.
A major bestseller in Italy and the winner of that country's most prestigious
literary award, Vita
brings to life three generations striving to
reconcile ambitious dreams and haunting memories. A marvelous transatlantic
journey, this is the great story of Italian immigration to America.
At the center of the novel are Vita and Diamante, childhood friends whose
loyalty was sealed during their treacherous voyage from Italy to Ellis Island at
the turn of the century. Vita's father runs a decrepit boarding house in lower
Manhattan, where shady tenants invent ruthless means of survival in a harsh
world of criminality. Yet Vita and Diamante believe in the promise of America, a
promise that will lead Diamante west, laboring in an industry rigged to imprison
him. Remaining in the city, Vita will learn how to thrive on danger, immersed in
clandestine worlds that are all too eager to claim this spirited and beautiful
young woman for themselves. When Vita and Diamante are at last reunited, they
spin an altered, world-wise dream, which will remain etched in their identities
for the rest of their lives. Future generations-including a World War II soldier
touring his mother's ravaged hometown, and an award-winning writer who is wary
of the States - will try to retrace the fate of these two extraordinary
immigrants. Each clue they unearth raises a tantalizing question, while Vita
tales gently simmer between truth and legend.
Questions for Discussion
- What is the effect of the novel's opening scene, in war-ravaged Tufo? What
significance did it have for you once you reached the last chapter? How does the
author's approach to the three timelines enhance her storytelling?
- How would you characterize Vita's relationship with her brother, Nicola
(Coca-Cola)? Are family ties meaningful in Agnello's house?
- When the narrator apprehensively makes her first trip to the United States
at age thirty, what does she discover? Does Little Italy retain any traces of
Vita and Diamante's experience when they arrived there nearly one hundred years
before? What compels the narrator (and all genealogists) to dig for details
- How does Vita's Prince Street community compare to other immigrant
neighborhoods featured in fiction? What events are unique to the
Italian-American immigrant experience?
- Why does Diamante lie to his parents in his letters home? What
consequences would there have been had they known the truth? How is he affected
by this separation from them? Throughout her life, how is Vita affected by
living so far away from her mother?
- How do the author's descriptions of the Black Hand differ from stereotypes
about organized crime? Is Vita more immune to intimidation than her father was?
- Does Lena's Circassian ancestry make her an outsider in the boarding
house? How do the residents feel about literacy and language, including Lena's
habit of speaking Neapolitan with Lebanese words mixed in?
- What do you make of the tragedies involving Lena, including the
"burial" of Baby and the fire ignited by Vita's wrath? Is Vita's
presence a sort of curse in Lena's life? Does Vita's supernatural gift wane as
she grows older, or does she simply get better at controlling it?
- What prevents Diamante from attaining financial success despite his
phenomenal ability to survive? Is he gullible, or is poverty his fate? Is his
passage back to Italy yet another trap? Or does leaving America ultimately free
- Part Two, "The Road Home," begins with a description of Dy's
entry into military service, despite a Princeton record that could have taken
him on a far more lucrative career path. What keeps him from feeling pride in
his ancestry? How does his nationalism compare to that of his uncle Nicola, who
died in the previous world war?
- How do you interpret the story of "The
Son of the Lady Tree," which Vita frequently recounts to Dy?
- Diamante and Vita become separated even after passing through Ellis
Island. Were they meant to be apart? Are Diamante's reasons for postponing their
relationship rational? Would their love have survived had they not spent so many
years envisioning a reunion? Does Diamante make "the path of their
existence diverge [and] those tracks welded together forever come apart,"
as the closing lines of "The Wreck of The Republic" suggest?
- Melania G. Mazzucco drew heavily on her own genealogical research to
create Vita. How were you affected by the inclusion of photographs, reports, and
other mementos in a novel? Is any novel purely fiction?
- Whose dreams are realized in the novel? Do Vita and Geremia join the
mindset of railroad and coal-mining robber barons when they venture into real
estate? What does it take for Geremia to rise above the rubble of his
- One of Diamante's first observations about his uncle Agnello's house is
that Rocco acknowledges him, and is one of the few tenants to do so in a
respectful way. Is Rocco entirely calculating, as when he buys guidebooks to
help him win a respectable bride? Does he ever act out of pure compassion?
- Discuss "Vita" as the title of the novel and as the name of its
heroine. How do the characters define vitality? What does it take for them to
live fully? How would you summarize their lives? Are love and life synonyms in
- The celebrities Enrico Caruso and Charlie Chaplin make cameo appearances
in the novel, taking the characters' futures in unexpected directions. In what
way do those stark images of famous entertainers contribute to Vita's tone?
- Why is Diamante unable to accept Dy's visit? What keeps him from
accepting Vita's final offer of love? Is Diamante's death, so soon after her
visit, a coincidence?
- How does twenty-first-century immigration to America compare to the Ellis
Island experience? Do today's immigrant neighborhoods resemble the streets Vita
first encountered here? What legends exist in your family's immigration stories?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Picador.
Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.