Please be aware that this discussion guide may contain spoilers!
Who is narrating? Discuss the use of the first person plural -- is it
effective? How does it alter your view of these friendships?
Who are "Our Kind"? What kind of women are they? How does the
narration, language and style reflect or enhance the story and the characters?
Share an example that you find particularly effective.
In "The Intervention," what does it mean when the narrator says,
"we've seen a lot, it's true, but know so little. How were we to learn?
Years ago we were led down the primrose lane, then abandoned somewhere near the
carp pond"? What is the significance of the intervention? At the chapter's
end, why does the narrator say, "We must save Him, quick. But first, no. We
must save ourselves"?
What is your response to Esther, in "Esther's Walter"? Do the
women really "love" her? Share your reactions to the group's
discussions while at Esther's. How do their actions speak louder than words? Why
is Walter's portrait important, and what does it represent? Discuss Esther's
"surprise." Compare what happened at the intervention and at Esther's
and discuss what these events tell you about the group.
Describe Bambi in "Bambi Breaks for Freedom." What does
Remington Jackson represent? What does her desire to see him represent?
To what does "Screw Martha" refer? What is symbolic about the
perception of, and what is to be done to, the geese at the country club?
Consider the paragraph near the end of "Screw Martha" that reads,
"She tilts the hard hat to show us the egg...dead." How is the
information in the passage imparted? Is the narrator reliable here? Why? Why
does the narrator wish "Barbara silent a bit longer," to
"return...to our green oasis, to the girls in their snowsuits...."?
What is the significance of the group gathering at the summer solstice in
"Come As You Were"? What does this chapter title mean? After the
sentence, "I hid in the armoire and wept, Gay begins", there is a long
parenthetical statement: "(What she needs is friends,...lover.)." What
is its significance? What affect does this have on your understanding of the
story, and the women in it?
In "Sick Chicks," focus on the paragraphs beginning, "The
group has not entirely assembled..." to "...the butter tong."
Consider the way the author describes the women entering the room, and the room
itself. What, if any, is the symbolism here? What makes Mrs. Dalloway
particularly good for the book discussion group at the hospice? What is Viv's
role in the discussion? Why is this scene set at a hospice?
Who are the "warriors" in the chapter with that title? Why is
Louise considered, "not of our set"? Do you think it's odd that the
group admits "we never knew a thing about Louise Cooper, or for that
matter, any of our pasts? We look ahead and speak of present things...".
Does this fit with what you know of the characters? What, if anything, is
significant about Louise's mask, her being photographed like a Madonna and then
her water breaking?
In "Back When They Were Children," what do the words lost
halcyon days represent to these women? Why are the words italicized? Are the
mothers very involved in their children's lives? In one another's lives? To what
does the chapter's last line refer -- "We've been told the dance will
In "The Hounds, Again," the geese are mentioned again --
"it is only a matter of time before the geese lose their fight." What
is really being discussed? To what does the chapter's title refer? Who is the
narrator talking about when she says, "it's Him we are remembering, Him we
will return to"? Look at the paragraph, "But now He does not look at
her,...His slipping tongue." Discuss what is going on and how Walbert
captures this all-to-common event in a woman's life, and whether or not she does
In "The Beginning of the End," Professor Dipple tells Viv:
"You might very well read a book from time to time....It will fade into
fuzzy thinking." What is she saying? What is Viv's response? What is Viv
recognizing here, at this turning point in her life? Why does Viv think,
"What possibly else" would she do but get married? What does it mean
when the narrator says, "The few times we speak of true things it is almost
unbearable"? What "true things" are unbearable?
Discuss the book's last line -- why does Viv say this moment is "the
beginning of the end"?
Looking at the book's structure, do the chapters work well independently?
How are they tied together? Could you change their order and still make the book
What time and place does Our Kind concern itself with? How does
Walbert signpost the era (pop culture references, political references, hair
styles, etc)? Discuss the cultural and generational limbo they find themselves
in. Are these women angry about the course of their lives? If not angry, then
what do they feel?
Unless otherwise stated, this discussion guide is reprinted with the permission of Scribner.
Any page references refer to a USA edition of the book, usually the trade paperback version, and may vary in other editions.
A Man Called Intrepid author dies aged 89(Dec 03 2013) William Stevenson, a journalist and author who drew on his close ties with intelligence sources to write two best-selling books in the 1970s, A Man Called...