Q&A with Alexander McCall Smith
written more than fifty books (from specialist titles such as Forensic
Aspects of Sleep to children's books, including The Perfect Hamburger). Was
The No.1 Ladies Detective Agency your first attempt at writing a mystery?
The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency is my first foray into this
territory, although I do not think of it as a mystery. I like to think of it as
a novel about a woman who happens to be a private detective. Mind you, I suppose
that makes it a mystery ... of a sort.
Your detective, Precious Ramotswe, is a wonderfully unique charactera
Batswana woman of traditional build who decides to become a professional private
detective. Is Precious based on someone that you knew when you lived in Botswana
or is she a creation of your imagination?
There is no particular person upon whom Precious Ramotswe is based,
but there is an incident. Years ago I was in Botswana, staying with friends in a
small town called Mochudi. A woman in the town wished to give my friends a
chicken to celebrate Botswana National Day. I watched as this
womantraditionally built, like Mma Ramotswechased the chicken round the
yard and eventually caught it. She made a clucking noise as she ran. The chicken
looked miserable. She looked very cheerful. At that moment I thought that I
might write a book about a cheerful woman of traditional build.
Did you know immediately that the story of Mma Ramotswe would be the basis
for an entire series of novels?
No, I did not. What happened is that I became so fond of the character
that I could not let her go. To leave her where she was at the end of the first
novel would have been rather like getting up and leaving the room in the middle
of a conversationrather rude.
It is rare for an author to explore the evolution from amateur sleuth to
professional detective, but one of the most appealing aspects of Precious's
character is that she doesn't always know what she's doing. In Tears of The
Giraffe (the sequel to The No1 Ladies' Detective Agency), she even sends away
for an instructional manual, Principles of Private Detection. What interests you
about "education of the detective"?
Mma Ramotswe sets up her agency without any relevant experience.
However, she does have intuitionin abundanceand that is very much more
important than anything she could learn from a book. In fact, the passages she
cites from The Principles of Private Detection are ultimately not particularly
helpful to her, the point being that a person without any training can achieve
great things if he or she has natural intelligence and ability. In many African
countries, including Botswana, people have great respect for books and for the
learning they contain. I would hope to point out that this should not obscure
the importance of real, practical wisdom.
Although Mma Ramotswe is confronted by greed, lust, dishonesty, and
murderous intent, these novels are rather optimistic and often humorous in tone.
How do you maintain this rather delicate balance?
> I think that many people living in Africain circumstances which are
sometimes quite difficultmaintain that balance themselves, and with great
dignity. I think that I merely reflect what is there in those fine people.
In the Precious Ramotswe novels, Botswana emerges as a vivid character and
a wonderful place to live. What do you hope that American readers will discover
about Africa while reading these novels?
I very much hope that American readers will get a glimpse of the
remarkable qualities of Botswana. It is a very special country and I think that
it particularly chimes with many of the values which Americans feel very
strongly aboutrespect for the rule of law and for individual freedom. I hope
that readers will also see in these portrayals of Botswana some of the
great traditional virtues in Africain particular, courtesy and a striking
How have these books been received in Botswana? What about other parts of
I was recently in Botswana and I was delighted to find that people
there liked the books. I was worried that they might have reservations about an
outsider writing about their society. No. They appear to like the way in which
their world is portrayed. I believe that they recognize themselves in them.
You were born in what is now known as Zimbabwe and you have also lived in
Botswana, the United States, and Edinburgh. In what ways have your international
travels informed your writing?
The fact that I have been all over the world means that I tend to use
a variety of locations for my work. I think it is important for a writer to
see other societies and attempt to understand them. Of course, you have to be
careful. It is easy to get things wrong. One might put palm trees in the wrong
place, for example in New York.
Do you see the Precious Ramotswe books within the context of the tradition
of the classic African novel of writers like Isak Dinesen and Chinua Achebe? Or
do you see them as a revamping of the mystery genre?
I think that these books might be difficult to put into any particular
tradition. They are obviously about Africa, but they are very different from the
works you mention. Some people say that they remind them of the novels of
that great Indian writer R.K. Narayan, which is very flattering, but I suppose I
can see the similarities in the world which his and my books portray.
Anthony Minghella, who has directed The English Patient and The
Talented Mr. Ripley recently optioned The No.1 Ladies' Detective
be a major motion picture. Will you be involved in the production in any way?
I hope that this goes ahead as planned. They have shown me a script,
which I read with interest. They said that I could come and see the shooting,
one of these days. I shall stand well back and I suspect that I shall say
The Precious Ramotswe books have a devoted following. Have you ever had
the opportunity to meet with the Mma Ramotswe fan club that is based in New
York? What question are you most frequently asked by your fans?
There seem to be many fans of the books in the U.S.A. I receive
wonderfully warm letters from American readers, which I greatly enjoy. As far as
New York is concerned, there is a splendid group of readers whom I met when I
was last there. They love Mma Ramotswe and she would love them too. They, like
many other readers, ask me when Mma Ramotswe and Mr J.L.B. Matekoni will
eventually get married. I must think about that.
Next spring, Pantheon Books will publish the fourth in the series of the
Precious Ramotswe novels. Will there be other books in the series as well?
I hope so. I am writing the fifth at the moment and I am thinking of
In addition to writing novels, you are also a professor of medical law at
Edinburgh University, and as if that wasn't enough to keep you busy, you also
conduct a symphony. How do you find the time to do it all?
I struggle to find the time to do things. I have many commitments, but
writing these books is such a pleasure for me that I shall always find the time,
somehow. I don't conduct a symphonyI play in a distinctly amateur
orchestra, of which I am the co-founder. I play the bassoon, but not the entire
instrument, as I dislike the very high notes and stop at the high D, which I
think is quite high enough. This orchestra is pretty awful, and that is why it
bears the name The Really Terrible Orchestra. This brings it a wide and
enthusiastic following. Recently we had a request from an American amateur
orchestra to use our name. We said of course. So somewhere in the U.S. there is
a bad amateur orchestra called The Really Terrible Orchestra. They will go