A Conversation with Jacqueline Winspear (2008)
Apart from being a series of wonderful mysteries, the Maisie Dobbs novels have helped to acquaint readers with a place and time of
which they might otherwise have known very little: England between the world
wars. What, at a minimum, would you like for your readers - especially your
non-British readers - to know about this period and what the First World War
did to British society?
One of the most gratifying things that has happened since the
books were published is that so many people have e-mailed or written to me to
tell me that my books have encouraged them to find out more about this period of
time and how the world was impacted by the Great War and the years until the
outbreak of the Second World War. I would like my readers to understand
something of history's gray areas, which are often well-served by fiction. For
example, we know about the Depression of the twenties and
thirties, and we know there was a Roaring Twenties, but that
only takes care of rich, poor, and rich becoming poor. The grand parties of the
twenties only roared for a certain echelon of society, and there was a whole
segment that was virtually untouched by the depression - which in itself was
experienced in different ways on either side of the Atlantic. My focus has
always been on what happens to ordinary people in extraordinary times. I hope my
readers see that history is a mirror - hold up the truth and we will see ourselves
and our time reflected there. Now, what do we do with that knowledge?
All of the Maisie Dobbs mysteries to date have been
deeply concerned with the lingering after effects of war. Having lived in
both England and the United States, do you think the two cultures tend to
have different understandings of this issue?
That's a tricky question. I don't think we have different
understandings as much as different levels of memory, and part of this is to do
with ways of looking at things. Personal experience of war is also vital to this
question. In Britain there is a real sense of "Lest We Forget" (you will see
this mirrored in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand). We do not have a Memorial
Day, which always seems to be more about sales and barbecues than about honoring
those who have fallen in wartime. Yet we have Remembrance Day, which many older
people still refer to as "Armistice Day," which falls on the Sunday closest to
the anniversary of the signing of the Armistice on November 11, 1918. And at 11:00 AM on November 11, Britain
honors the dead with two minutes of silence. Whether you are in Safeway doing
your shopping, or on a train, or a plane, or just walking along the street,
people will be still and silent to honor the dead of all wars, whether it was
the Great War, the Falklands War, or Iraq.
The aftereffects of war - especially
the Great War - impacted almost every family in Britain, and changed life and
society forever. A woman might have lost her husband, brother, cousins, and
sons. A street would lose all its boys on one day, in one battle. And bear this
in mind - in the Great War you could hear the guns in northern France from the
south-coast communities in England, and of course, in the Second World War there
were more civilian casualties than military in the first two years of the war.
And those memories linger, are demonstrated in subsequent generations. It is
only in recent years that London, for example, dealt with some of the last WW2
bomb sites. So perhaps it is the proximity of war that influences understanding,
although now, with our twenty-four-hour all-color media, "proximity" has taken
on a new meaning again. It's a big topic, and not one easily addressed in a
We've actually been wondering more generally about your
creative influences and the kinds of things that inspire you. What other
writers, either in or out of the mystery genre, have you seen as influences
You know, I can't say that any one writer has inspired my
writing, so that I yearn to write in their style or manner, however, as a reader
and as an observer of the world around me, I am inspired all the time. I am a
great fan of that cadre of authors from the Maxwell Perkins stable in the early
part of the twentieth century - F. Scott Fitzgerald, Ernest Hemingway, John Dos
Passos. I am a huge fan of John Steinbeck. I reread the classics as often as I
can, and am particularly fond of Jane Austen. I love Somerset Maugham, George
Orwell, Aldous Huxley, and Evelyn Waugh. More recent authors I particularly
enjoy (and here's a broad spread!) are Susan Howach, Barbara Kingsolver, Terry
Tempest Williams, David Lodge, Iris Murdoch, Muriel Spark, Anne Tyler, Jhumper
Lahiri - the list goes on! For non-book inspiration, there's riding my horse - as
Winston Churchill said, "No hour is ever wasted, that is spent in the saddle."
I am inspired by good writing whatever the source, from theater
and film, to poetry and memoir. People inspire me - I am an observer of people at
airports, you see all sorts of interesting things going on when people are in
Much of your writing about Maisie has derived from
stories that have been passed down in your family. An Incomplete Revenge,
for example, is somewhat based on your parents' experiences of going "down
hopping." What was it about these stories that most interested you?
I went hop-picking as a child, too, so I remember it well. I am
engaged by family stories because they reflect our personal connection to
different times, different places - and the way that time can render a place we
know well all but unrecognizable, except from the heart. Looking through that
window to personal social history fascinates me because it is so much more than
an intellectual exercise - it is a spiritual and emotional connection to what has
We tend to look to people in certain occupations,
including ministers and educators, to uphold values like tolerance,
fairness, and honesty. In An Incomplete Revenge,
however, the representatives of these professions do not fare too well. You
have a thieving, lying minister and a school headmaster who turns a blind
eye to bullying and intolerance. Why did you choose to represent these
characters in such a dubious light?
I didn't "choose" - it just happened that way. But perhaps it goes
back to that curiosity about the gray areas. You will find kindness and
compassion among villains as many times as you find greed, bullying, and
intolerance among the pillars of society.
Your familiarity with gypsy words and customs seems quite
extensive. How did you come to possess this knowledge?
It's a long story, but suffice it to say that a gypsy
family - real Roma, not the pseudo-gypsies one reads about in Britain's tabloids
today - were counted among my parents' dearest friends many years ago. Even as
"gorja" my parents were welcomed as if they were family, and came to know their
language and customs.
The gypsies in your novel choose not to assimilate, and,
by remaining separate, they preserve their vitality and dignity. By
contrast, the Martins, who crave acceptance within society, suffer
horrifically for their efforts. Is it somehow strange that in a novel that
stresses the importance of including those whom we perceive as "other,"
those who embrace separateness are in some ways better off for having done
It didn't occur to me that it was strange, to tell you the
truth. It's just the way the story emerged. However, remember the gypsy tribe
looked "different" and as a proud people would not have tried to assimilate,
especially as their lifestyle would take them away again as soon as the work
ended. People who move a lot - like military families, for example - tend to feel
more grounded with others who live in the same way, who understand their way of
An Incomplete Revenge is prefaced with a
quotation: "There is no revenge so complete as forgiveness." And, of course,
the failure to forgive in the novel is the reason that the revenge in your
title is incomplete. Yet isn't it true that some acts are so horrible that
true forgiveness is impossible?
That depends on how you see forgiveness. I view forgiveness as
the thing that lets you off the hook if you are wronged by another. If I do not
forgive, that event/person/whatever it is that I do not want to forgive will
have a power over my life. One's view of such a powerful emotion is extremely
personal. Would I forgive the person who killed someone I loved? I don't know.
But I would try. My soul would demand that I try.
It seems to us that
An Incomplete Revenge has something very
wise and powerful to say about the nature of evil: that it may actually be
within our power to destroy it only if we can master the arts of forgiveness
and letting go. At the same time, though, if we do
let the author of the evil go unpunished, and this result has its own kind
of injustice. How are we to find a balance between the need to forgive and
the need to punish?
Now you're asking me some questions that the wise struggle with!
This is where you go into those gray areas, which means there isn't a stock
answer. However, punishment is to do with revenge, and when powered by blind
intense emotion can have a devastating impact far beyond those wronged and those
who would do harm. I would have different responses, say, to the punishment of a
billionaire corporate titan who knowingly played fast and loose with employee
pensions, and the parent who tracks down the person who assaulted their child
and causes them personal harm. And that's why we have a system of justice, no
matter how flawed it may seem at times. It is supposed to bring clarity to the
matter, so that we do not mete out our own punishment while the soul is so
pained it cannot see.
There's an old saying, "He who seeks revenge should dig two
graves." It gives one pause for thought.
Simon Lynch's long
disability and Maisie's devotion to him give you the opportunity to develop
a strong heroine while maintaining a plausible reason for denying her much
of an active love interest. With Simon now gone, Maisie evidently faces a
crossroads. As we look forward to Maisie's next adventure, should we expect
more romance in her life, or will she travel on, majestically single? Or
would you rather not say?
I think I would rather not say. What a spoiler that would be!
An Interview with Jacqueline Winspear (2005)
Who is Maisie and what inspired her?
I had not planned to write fiction. Even though one of my
writing mentors had encouraged me to give it serious thought at that point my
passion was the personal essay. However, I was driving to work one morning,
crawling along in heavy traffic, then stuck at a stop light, when I did what
many people do in those conditions - I started daydreaming. Suddenly, in my
mind's eye, I saw a woman - dressed in the fashion of the late 1920's - on the
old wooden escalator at Warren Street station in London. She left the station,
walked down Warren Street and stopped outside one of the houses, whereupon she
took out an envelope with a set of keys. The scene continued, even as I heard
the car horn from the driver behind me (the light had changed). I couldn't wait
to get home that evening to write what I had seen that morning, which was
essentially the first chapter of Maisie Dobbs, the first novel in the
series. The thing was, that I knew so much about the character of Maisie before
I had even reached work that day. She was born in Lambeth, a very poor area of
south-east London, at the tail end of the 1800's. Her rise from the position of
a maid working in service is due to her intelligence, intellect, and in no small
part to her other intuitive gifts gifts that are recognized by Dr. Maurice
Blanche, a friend of her employer. She wins a place to study at Girton College,
Cambridge, but cuts her education short in 1915 when she enlists for nursing
service. After the war, she continues her education, then works for Blanche as
his assistant. Blanche's history is complex following medical training he also
worked in "legal medicine" (forensics) and is a psychologist and, as readers
come to know, also something of a philosopher. We first meet Maisie following
his retirement, when she is setting up in business on her own.
It appears that your heroine is continually coming up against
the dilemma of how to do her job as an investigator without letting her life - or
her past - interfere. How does the theme of telling "pardonable lies" figure into
At the age of 18, Maisie was plunged into the horror of war
first-hand when she was sent to France as a nurse at a casualty clearing station
(CCS), which was very close to the front lines. In a way, she lost part of
herself there - not only was she injured when the CCS was shelled, but she saw
death at its most horrific, and its saddest. In Pardonable Lies she is
required to return to France, a daunting prospect. It is like driving along a
road where one has had a bad car accident from which one still suffers you
really would rather take another route. In Pardonable Lies, Maisie knows
she is compromised, and the reader understands, too, that Maisie's suffering has
never abated, that in her way she is as shell-shocked as many of the soldiers
who returned from that war. In addition, Maisie is driven to ensure that, during
an investigation, those she touches in the course of her work are left at peace
with her actions, as far as that is possible. That struggle is at the heart of
Pardonable Lies. The title was inspired by the following words:
Truly, to tell lies is not honorable;
but when the truth entails tremendous ruin,
to speak dishonorably is pardonable.
-- Sophocles (496BC-406BC), Creusa
Why did you choose the time following World War I for your
novels? Do you have a particular interest in that time period?
My grandfather was severely wounded and shell-shocked at The
Battle of the Somme in 1916. Even as a young child, I understood the extent of
his suffering. When I asked questions about his profound limp and wheezy lungs,
my mother would tell me that "Grandad was wounded in the Great War." It seemed
such a terrible thing to me, most probably due to the gravity with which the
words "Great War" were spoken. In fact, I can remember the very first time I
asked questions about my grandfather's health. I think I was about five at the
time. My grandparents came to stay once or twice a year, coming down on the
steam train from London for a week or two at a time. During one of those early
visits, I heard my grandfather get up very early. I waited for him to go
downstairs, then clambered out of bed and followed him down. I sat on the stairs
and peeked through the wooden rail. I saw him soaking his feet and calves,
drying them and massaging his legs up and down. Then I saw my grandfather begin
to remove something from his leg, then another, and another. Later, I asked what
Granddad was doing and my mother explained to me as best she could to a child
that he was removing shrapnel from his legs, shrapnel embedded when he went
"over the top" during the Battle of the Somme. Of course, you can imagine the
"what" and "why" questions that followed, however, I was left with an overriding
image the picture of darkness, of guns and of my grandfather wounded on the
ground. I later learned that throughout my father's childhood, my grandfather
was periodically taken away by ambulance for a month or so, perhaps to a
soldiers convalescent home by the sea, so that he could breathe in fresh air to
help his gas-damaged lungs. My grandfather died when he was 77, and to the day
he died he was still removing shrapnel from his wounds of over fifty years
As I grew up my curiosity about the "war to end all wars"
deepened, so that I always seemed to be reading something about the war.
However, my interest was not in the politics of the time so much as rooted in
the experiences of ordinary men and women, boys and girls, not only on the
battlefield, but on the home front. And though I never set out to write a "war"
novel, it came as no surprise that this part of history formed the backdrop of
Maisie Dobbs and other books in the series.
For me, the war and its aftermath provide fertile ground for a
mystery, offering a literary vehicle for exploring the time. Such great social
upheaval allows for the strange and unusual to emerge and a time of intense
emotions can, to the writer of fiction, provide ample fodder for a compelling
story, especially one concerning criminal acts and issues of guilt and
innocence. After all, a generation is said to have lost its innocence in The
What research have you done in order to reconstruct this time so
My research is ongoing. Books and records from and about the
period are the mainstay of my personal library. I also read memoirs, fiction
from the period, mainly to enhance my sense of language, of societal mores, etc.
In addition, I do a considerable amount of
primary research, which includes, for example, consulting the
archives at the Imperial War Museum in London, walking the streets where I am
setting scenes and then comparing what I can see and feel today with old photos
and accounts of life at the time. Last year I went to France and Belgium as part
of my research for Pardonable Lies. It was a profound experience, because I
walked sections of the battlefields of the Somme and Ypres, even found live
ammunition from the war some 90 years ago (there's an essay about that trip on
my website). What I constantly had to do was to imagine how that place might
have looked twelve years after the war, in 1930, when Maisie has to return to
France as part of her investigation into the death of a wartime aviator.
How is Maisie Dobbs an example of how women lived during that
time and what they were able to accomplish?
One of the things I wanted to do in creating the character of
Maisie Dobbs was to honor the spirit of that generation of women in Britain.
They were the first generation of women in modern times to go into war related
work, and they did so in the hundreds of thousands. Some 60,000 women went
directly into war-related roles, as nurses, ambulance drivers, code-breakers,
munitions workers, and in military support roles. Just shy of another 500,000
women assumed men's jobs so that men could be released to the battlefield. There
was barely a field of endeavor untouched by a woman's hand they built ships,
built aircrafts, drove trains and buses, worked the land, the first women police
auxiliaries pounded the London streets, women worked in construction and in
brewing they did everything. But the sad thing is that they were a generation
for whom life would never be as they might have expected it to be when they were
girls in the years before the war. The 1921 census revealed that there were two
million "surplus" women in Britain. Approximately 750,000 men of marriageable
age were killed in the war, and about 1,350,000 came home seriously wounded and
shell-shocked. Of course, those "surplus" women became the subject of jokes and
speculation, and were often seen as something to be feared (heaven knows what
they might get up to!). The truth is that they were an extraordinary generation.
Plunged into war, having lost sweethearts and young husbands, brothers and
fathers, women now had to be financially independent, they had to build
community and friendships, and they had to prepare for growing old alone. The
accomplishments and resolve of that generation is inspiring for example, it
was the great age of women novelists in Britain.
In Pardonable Lies, psychics and their work figure prominently
into the plot. Do you believe that certain people possess the ability to conjure
up the past and see the future? Is there a connection on some level to the work
that Maisie does? Where does your interest in psychics' work stem from?
There are two different things here. First, there is Maisie's
work and some of the techniques she uses to gain the truth of a person or
situation. I believe there are some who are more attuned to the "inner voice"
and who listen to their intuition more keenly and act upon it accordingly.
Maisie is such a person, deeply attuned to her inner voice and able to gain a
sense of a person's innermost thoughts and feelings from the way a person walks,
words chosen, and so on. She gives credence to any sensations indicating that
danger is close, or that someone is not who they claim to be, and this
super-sensitivity can be interpreted as a psychic ability. Some of her methods
were in their infancy in the early years of the last century, and I was
informed by a psychologist once that in her work she uses the same "mirroring"
technique as Maisie.
In the years of the Great War and the post-war period, there
were thousands of people in Britain who believed in the power of psychics and
mediums. And 1917 was the year in which more ouija boards were sold in Britain
than at any other time - use of the ouija board is now illegal there. So many
men died so suddenly in the Great War, that there was a collective yearning for
contact. Imagine this - a whole village of men could be lost in minutes as they
went "over the top" into battle. The occult offered the possibility of that
final communication with a loved one, a chance to say, "Farewell" or "I love
you" that was not offered in any other quarter. There were so many charlatans
who took advantage of the bereaved, as well as those who wanted to do good but
had no more ability to speak to the dead than the next person. I should add,
though, that the term 'occult' is used here in accordance with a more universal
meaning: the deeper spiritual reality that cannot be understood using pure
reason or material science. The modern interpretations tend towards the
derogatory and point to an evil connotation.
When you begin writing your novels, do you have the details of
who did what, where, when and why mapped out specifically or do they develop as
I have a basic idea of the who, the what and the where a map
of where I am going. The wonderful thing about a map is that it allows you to be
more of an adventurer, because if you lose your way, you have something to come
back to. Though I have key markers in the plot mapped out, I am also able to go
off down another road if I am led there by curiosity, a dream or just my fingers
on the keyboard.
Do you have to read Maisie Dobbs and Birds of a Feather before
you read this one?
Pardonable Lies can definitely be read out of sequence, because
I have woven just enough basic history from the first two novels to enable
readers to grasp the background quite readily. However, any series, there is
something to be gained from reading earlier books. It's not essential reading,
but I think the readers of Pardonable Lies will enjoy going back to read the
first two books.
Can you tell us what is next for Maisie?
Messenger of Truth is set in early 1931. Nicholas "Nick" Bassington-Hope, a controversial artist and veteran of the Great War, now on the
cusp of fame, is found dead. His demise from a fall on the night before a much
anticipated exhibition of his work at a famed Albemarle Street gallery is
recorded as "accidental." The victim's twin sister, a former Girton student and
wartime journalist who disguised herself as a man to get close to the
battlefield, comes to Maisie Dobbs for help. Despite all evidence to the
contrary, Georgina Bassington-Hope believes her brother was murdered. Maisie
takes on the case, which will take her from the underbelly of London's art world
to the desolate beaches of Dungeness in Kent. Her immersion in her work
threatens her budding romance with Andrew Dene, and an unexpected visitor needs
her help, as does a desperate Beale family.